As mentioned many times in the past, the problem with such threads is that it becomes difficult to stop people from commenting against some specific suhabas (r.a) which can not be tolerated here, because a lot of readers respect them and don't want to listen to anything disrespectful against them.
Brother AliJan, if you search past threads you would realize that most of them were closed because of the same reason. We can't stop everyone from making comments, because they have a right to share here their beliefs, but at the same time we can't allow disrespect of people whom any particular group of people love and respect.
I have no other option but to also close this thread, because when people can't come to common terms and have major differences in beliefs, it leads to personal attacks and hurting of feelings of the readers. Let us concentrate on the matters that would be asked from us in grave regarding "our own deeds" instead of controversial matters, the ultimate judgment of which only belongs to Allah (swt).