HADITH ABOUT HZ. ALI RA

Society Religion & Philosophy
21

Re: HADITH ABOUT HZ. ALI RA

Yes I am alhamdulilah bot you are not proving yourself to be one. You have still not grapsed the sarcastic question of mine in post 17, so leaving it anyways.

22

Re: HADITH ABOUT HZ. ALI RA

READ THIS BOOK

Shiite muhaditeen like Abu Faraj al-Isfahani in his Muqatil at-Talibeen-p.88,142,188; Al-Arbali in his Kashful Ghumamah vol.2,p.64; and Majlisi in Jila el-ou’ioun 582 stated that amongst those who were martyred with Hussein in Karbala were Abu Bakr ibn Ali ibn Abi Talib and Abu Bakr ibn Hussein ibn Ali ibn Abi Talib.
Why doesn’t the ceremonies held during Ashoora not mention the names of the following who were martyred with Hussein:
Umar ibn Ali ibn Abi Talib
Abu Bakr ibn Ali ibn Abi Talib
Uthman ibn Ali ibn Abi Talib
Abu Bakr ibn Hassan ibn Ali
Umar ibn Hassan ibn Ali
Abu Bakr ibn Hussein ibn Ali
Umar ibn Hussein ibn Ali
Uthman ibn Hussein ibn Ali.

Is it because that the likes of Abu Bakr and Umar wiped out the Sassanid arrogance and for this reason mentioning their names are unbearable?

Muhammad Ali Mu’zi, an Iranian Shiite researcher in France has stated with pride: “The basic fundamentals of the Zoroastrian religion has entered into Shiaism even in some minute issues. The marriage of Imam Hussein with the daughter of the last Sassanid Empire is a symbol of ancient Iran as Shahrbano became the first mother or lady for the Iranian nation. And this relationship marked the brotherhood between Shiaism and the ancient Magian Iran.”

23

Re: HADITH ABOUT HZ. ALI RA

Once again, not interested in it since I do not ask you to copy paste it. Secondly, Isfahani was not a Shia Muhadith.

24

Re: HADITH ABOUT HZ. ALI RA

so, you mean what written in his books are sunnies bliefs,
tell me what shia says about 28 offspring of hz. ali ra.

and also so called 12 imams do you aware what name of their sons and doughters.

if you have provide us full details of your so called 12 imams offsprings.

25

Re: HADITH ABOUT HZ. ALI RA

It seems that you yourself dont know what you are typing but you just have to make a post here.

26

Re: HADITH ABOUT HZ. ALI RA

what i have i already post and it was from authentic source, i need your view on 28 offspring of hz. ali ra and their name with name of childrens of your so called 12 imams.

27

Re: HADITH ABOUT HZ. ALI RA

I dont know why people influnced by the rhetoric of Anujam Sipah Sahaba [ASS] stoop low to comment on non-issues. What exactly you want to do with the names of sons of Ali bin Abi Talib [as]? When did this 'naming' thing become a issue between the two sects?

28

Re: HADITH ABOUT HZ. ALI RA

you did not aware that not only ssp even ahmed raza khan of braili, india (founder of bralivi maslaq) and four imams of of ahlul sunna and from era of sahaba till todate no one bliefs that hz. ali ra was belong to shia sect.

ummah need to aware that how many childrens of hz. ali ra and what was name of these childrens since shia claims that hz. ali ra was imam and he ra was shia why why he ra named his sons on the name of their enemies (as per shia thoughts).

so, if you have name of 28 childrens of hz. ali ra, why you affraid to post.

29

Re: HADITH ABOUT HZ. ALI RA

What SSP [formerly ASS] or someother thinks is not our concerned. They have themselves made severe takfeer against eachother, so they better solve their own problems first.

As for naming the children on their enemies, thats what I have been asking you since day one, did you receive any revealation that He [as] named then ONLY because the 'enemies' had those respective names?

30

Re: HADITH ABOUT HZ. ALI RA

If i have a son and i name him Salman does it mean tht i love and accept everything done by Salman Rushdie? and if my son is called salman then how could 1 tell wht my true inspirations are....is it the great companion salman farsi or is it salman ahmad the guitarist or salman taseer the politician or salman khan the actor? this is wht BOY-NICE is asking for jan1001 to prove but i think he is expectng too much from a person like him...
Its quite a silly argument but nevertheless nt too surprising coming from a person like jan1001...

31

Re: HADITH ABOUT HZ. ALI RA

Thsi topic has been beaten to death, i see no point.