someone who had a broken engagement before meeting you? and what if he/she wants to break their engagement after meeting you?.
Honest answers pls.
Re: Guys & Girls: Would you be ok marrying…
Then that person, who’s willing to mess up someone else’s life and who isn’t even sure being with you, isn’t worth it :k:
Re: Guys & Girls: Would you be ok marrying...
I dont think anything wrong with it, engagement is not a marriage or nikkah and there are many valid reasons to break it.
Re: Guys & Girls: Would you be ok marrying...
^Agree..
If he had a good reason it wouldn't bother me..
Re: Guys & Girls: Would you be ok marrying...
It really depends on the situation and I expect more information to answer your question.
Re: Guys & Girls: Would you be ok marrying...
Then that person, who's willing to mess up someone else's life and who isn't even sure being with you, isn't worth it
How is breaking an engagement messing up someone's life?
Re: Guys & Girls: Would you be ok marrying...
Yeah if the reason is valid for breaking the engagement then no harm done
Re: Guys & Girls: Would you be ok marrying...
someone who had a broken engagement before meeting you?
yup i would be ok but depends on the situation.
and what if he/she wants to break their engagement after meeting you?.
it depends on the situation i mean if they break their engagement just cause they have met me now and then it will be NO because if they have broken their engagement with that person then one day they can break their engagement with me too once they have met someone else. other wise it will be ok.
all in all i will leave it to my parents. what ever they decide.
Re: Guys & Girls: Would you be ok marrying...
someone who had a broken engagement before meeting you?
Yes things happen
and what if he/she wants to break their engagement after meeting you?.
*Nope, thats not right in my book........if he's engaged he shouldn't be interested elsewhere * Honest answers pls.
Don't know if I grasped what you were asking for the second question
Re: Guys & Girls: Would you be ok marrying...
It really depends on the situation and I expect more information to answer your question.
what info? it was just a general question i came up with after reading a topic here.
Don't know if I grasped what you were asking for the second question
say i m engaged but i come across a guy n fall in love with him lol. then is it ok 2 break my engagement n go with the other guy?
Re: Guys & Girls: Would you be ok marrying...
someone who had a broken engagement before meeting you? and what if he/she wants to break their engagement after meeting you?.
Honest answers pls.
For the first scenario... yes I would. In fact I would prefer a broken engagement over a past affair.
For the second scenario... no I wouldn't. If he is leaving someone for me today, he could leave me for another person tomorrow.
Re: Guys & Girls: Would you be ok marrying...
For the first scenario... yes I would. In fact I would prefer a broken engagement over a past affair. For the second scenario... no I wouldn't. If he is leaving someone for me today, he could leave me for another person tomorrow.
so u wud recommend they stay in a relationship where they dnt feel the love for their partner? and its not marriage just engagement.
Re: Guys & Girls: Would you be ok marrying…
I never said or implied that. And I don’t understand how did you reach that conclusion from my post 
PS: i was talking of an arranged marriage scenario… now someone who is engaged wouldn’t go around looking for a spouse would they?
Re: Guys & Girls: Would you be ok marrying...
someone who had a broken engagement before meeting you? yup i would be ok but depends on the situation.
and what if he/she wants to break their engagement after meeting you?. it depends on the situation i mean if they break their engagement just cause they have met me now and then it will be NO because if they have broken their engagement with that person then one day they can break their engagement with me too once they have met someone else. other wise it will be ok.
^ Agree with above.
Re: Guys & Girls: Would you be ok marrying…
sometimes you are not even looking for love but it happens or so i suppose from what i see around.
i myself am nt in favor of it like what happened in the movie kank but it does happen n marriage is an altogether diff thing but i think if within engagement you dnt feel the love or find love elsewhere it shudnt be THAT big deal. It wont be easy but def nt something u shudnt go for.
Re: Guys & Girls: Would you be ok marrying…
Life is not a bollywood movie 
Re: Guys & Girls: Would you be ok marrying…
While engagement ‘by itself’ has no big value, however a lot goes on during engagement period and maybe actual wedding day is very close.
Also, falling in love with someone on the spur may be something people do but there should be more reasons for the engaged person to fall in love with someone ENOUGH that breaking of engagement is considered.
Either the person is just not so much in to marrying with engaged partner (or whaever reason) or a loony who falls in love with anyone who he/she finds attractive. 
So answer cannot be so simple as yes or no.
A lot needs to be considered since making and breaking relations is not like buying new shirt!..
…or maybe it is:hmmm:
Re: Guys & Girls: Would you be ok marrying...
I'll go for it but would be really wary of the guy and do my homework on him to find out the real reasons behind the breakup before I said yes.
Re: Guys & Girls: Would you be ok marrying...
A broken engagement isnt a big deal at all and wouldnt alarm me. I would of course want to know the circumstances behind it though.
Would I be okay if he tried to break his existing commitment to be with me?
No.
Re: Guys & Girls: Would you be ok marrying...
A broken engagement?! gasp She is SO second hand! How dare she?!