Gupzine

The way this idea had been inititally sold by ravage, I had been under the impression that it was akin to a peer reviewed journal. I just noticed though that anyone can submit anything. How is that any different from these forums then aside from maybe the length being longer? I think articles should be reviewed before getting “published” otherwise it’s just these forums morphed a little bit.

Re: Gupzine

You can submit an article any time, but they don't get published before being reviewed ppl editors.

Re: Gupzine

Who is reviewing? :)

Re: Gupzine

it is peer reviewed. we'll be releasing guidelines for authors and details on the reviewing process in a few days which should clear things up a little.

Re: Gupzine

Well, spell check at the very least.

Re: Gupzine

lol.. im sure thats in the guidelines.. spotted a typo have we?

Re: Gupzine

Too many grammatical mistakes! it's vs. its etc.

Re: Gupzine

Thanks Sarah for your input and concern.

I think you've been properly informed by ravage that it's going to be a peer-reviewed process, and it is going to be something substantially different than the main forum.

Spelling mistakes, how regrettable they are, cannot always be avoided, especially at the beginning of such undertaking.

As ravage has indicated more formal guidelines will be up shortly, to even out these things.

Re: Gupzine

Thanks Nescio for the expected token response.

Re: Gupzine

hmmm, apart from a diplomatically correct answer, i think i also covered all your inquiries (peer review, difference from normal forum -anyone submitting-, spelling/grammatical errors), or did you have an other more specific question?

Re: Gupzine

hmm.. perhaps u can pm me the articles in question? I reviewed just one and got lucky in not finding any ..

Re: Gupzine

The article system will ultimately become a concise collection of pearls that lie abundant within the GS community. The link to GZine will be available from the main portal for the advantage of those who do not know how to navigate GS or are pressed for time. Consider this as a continuation of our tradition to serve you more and better.

Re: Gupzine

Hahahaha! You go girl!

Re: Gupzine

this is actually a nice idea. people from around the world can share their experiences and we can create an “online” megazine. maybe i can interview some famous stars for the entertainment section :smooth:

when will “I” be a star??? :bummer:

Re: Gupzine

oh whenever I will be a star, anyone of you can interview me for the entertainment section of “Gupzine” :snooty:

Re: Gupzine

TNW,
sure! if you have access to any prominent personalities just go right ahead! :k:

Re: Gupzine

first call my secretary for an appointment :snooty:

Re: Gupzine

have you attemtpted to make fun of me :bummer: I swear I’ve met many famous stars :bummer:

i have pictures with some but not all.

Re: Gupzine

Kristie Alley and/or Ruben Studdard don’t count as “many” stars.

Re: Gupzine

Im Kool, I was talking abt pakistani stars for "Gupzine"