Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees

Interesting read…

Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees  - NY Daily News

Death threats are just another part of life for Terry Holdbrooks Jr.

The ex-U.S. Army employee converted to Islam in 2003, inspired by the faith of the Guantanamo detainees he was charged with watching. Since then, he says he has lost his friends, received violent threats, and been labeled a “race traitor” online.

But he hasn’t gone quietly. The 29-year-old has done his fair share of media and has even signed on for a job as a speaker for the Muslim Legal Fund of America. Now the devout Muslim is racking up frequent flyer miles and touring the country with what he calls the “truth about Gitmo.”

“Gitmo was supposed to be a cushy deployment since we were just going to babysit detainees,” Holdbrooks said. “But it changed me.”

The Phoenix, Ariz., resident spent the year between 2003 and 2004 guarding U.S. military prisoners at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. He was often given the job of escorting detainees to interrogation rooms. He says he witnessed atrocities committed by his fellow American soldiers that he never thought were possible.

RELATED: OBAMA REDEFINES TERROR WAR, RULES FOR DRONE

Speaking on the phone to the Daily News, Holdbrooks rattled off the grim list.

“I saw people put in stress positions for eight hours until they defecated themselves,” he said. “Then the guards would come in and emasculate them.”

He said he saw prisoners shackled to the ground with the air conditioner set high, then doused with cold water. He said that menstrual blood was smeared on their faces and that they were forced to hear the same music on repeat for hours.
Roughly 100 prisoners at the facility are reportedly on a hunger strike to protest their indefinite detentions.
Shane T. McCoy/Department of Defense via AP
Roughly 100 prisoners at the facility are reportedly on a hunger strike to protest their indefinite detentions.

“Gitmo is 100 percent antithetical to the basis of our legal system,” he said. “That’s not the America I signed up to defend.”

While preparing for deployment, Holdbrooks said the Army trained him to think of the prisoners as the “worst of the worst” and “lower than humans.”

RELATED: GUANTANAMO BAY GUARDS, PRISONERS CLASH OVER HUNGER STRIKE

“They said these were Al Quaida and Taliban, people who hate America and hate freedom,” Holdbrooks said.

But at least 86 of the 166 men currently held in the detention center have been cleared for release. Some have been held for years without formal charges. They are unable to transfer out because of restrictions in their home countries and laws passed by Congress, according to Human Rights Watch.

Despite the trying situations, Holdbrooks noticed that the men he talked to clung to their faith. He wondered how they could believe that there was a god who cared about them.

“I had all the freedom in the world,” he recalls. “But I was waking up unhappy while these men were in cages, smiling and praying five times a day.”

As a teenager, Holdbrooks had searched for truths in several different religions. He came to Guantanamo convinced that all monotheistic religions were evil.

RELATED: PETITION TO CLOSE GUANTANAMO BAY TOPS 75,000 SIGNATURES
Holdbrooks (not pictured) said he was often responsible for leading detainees to interrogation rooms.
MARC SEROTA/REUTERS
Holdbrooks (not pictured) said he was often responsible for leading detainees to interrogation rooms.

But over the course of several months, as Holdbrooks started speaking to the detainees and reading the Quran, he began to find some truth in Islam.

“The Quran is the simplest book in the world to read. It doesn’t have magic. It doesn’t contradict itself,” Holdbrooks said. “It’s simply an instruction manual for living.”

The faith lives of the detainees seemed to be proof that the instruction manual could work.

Holdbrooks took the leap in December 2003. In the presence of the prisoners, he read out a statement of faith that confirmed him as a Muslim.

His life changed drastically when he came back to America. He said he spent years trying to drink away memories of Guantanamo. He was honorably discharged from the Army in October 2005 for “generalized personality disorder.”

RELATED: US NAMES 55 GUANTANAMO DETAINEES TO BE TRANSFERRED TO OTHER COUNTRIES

Then, Holdbrooks decided to renew his commitment to Islam. He stopped drinking, smoking, and doing drugs. He put a stop to promiscuity and profanity. He found discipline in prayer.

And he started speaking out.

“Islam teaches you that if you see an injustice in the world, you should do anything within your power to stop it,” Holdbrooks said.
The Guantanamo Bay detention center is located on the southeastern coast of Cuba.
BOB STRONG/REUTERS
The Guantanamo Bay detention center is located on the southeastern coast of Cuba.

Wary of misinterpretation, Holdbrooks makes sure to speak to reporters and his lecture audiences with precision. He clarifies everything he says, knowing all the while every public appearance will result in some sort of condemnation. Still, he pores through the hundreds of crude Internet comments to see if someone has heard his message.

“The people who write these negative comments think they’re Islamic scholars,” Holdbrooks said. “But they’re actually making massive generalized statements about something they have no idea about.”

RELATED: SENATE VOTES TO BAR TRANSFER OF GUANTANAMO BAY DETAINEES TO U.S. FOR ANOTHER YEAR

His agenda isn’t to promote religion, he said. Instead, he’s thinking about the human rights of people like Shaker Aamer, a detainees who turned into his mentor. Aamer, the last British resident at Guantanamo, has been detained for 11 years. He has never been charged for a crime and has been cleared for release twice, the BBC reports.

Aamer is now one of the prisoners participating in a massive hunger strike behind bars.

“These things aren’t America,” Holdbrooks said. “It would be wrong if I sat by and let Gitmo continue to exist or let people think that Islam is America’s greatest enemy.”

Re: Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees

Peace Shamraz

Thanks for posting this … It means a lot.

.

.

Re: Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees

eye-opening indeed.
thanks for posting.

can someone please explain to me how prisoners that have been held without charges and have been cleared for release on more than one occasion are still behind bars at Gitmo?

Re: Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees

In the case of Shaker Aamer, I read in The Guardian that the British secret service doesn't want him back in UK.

"It has been suggested that British secret service agents were present while Aamer was tortured by US interrogators, who repeatedly smashed his head against a wall, prior to his transportation to Guantánamo. It has also been suggested that Aamer's allegation of British complicity in his torture has led to the British secret service actively lobbying against his release."

The US on the other hand alleges that Britain's commitment to detainee's release is half-hearted. So basically no one cares.

Re: Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees

I think there are many in Gitmo who were captured falsely. True.
But the punishments he cited are far less than what Muslim dictators have perpetrated on their political opponents. For example, torture techniques of Saddam and Hosni Mubarak.

Re: Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees

so both countries are in it together as usual.....
but why doesn't some other muslim nation step up and take him in?

Re: Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees

so that justified torture at Gitmo? pata nahin Musalmano ka khoon hi kiyun sasta hai her taraf :bummer:

Re: Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees

musalmano nay apni qeemat khud hi gira’ee hai…
if we had unity within us we wouldn’t be where we are.

Re: Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees

Is this about my post?
No. It does not justify. I am just saying that we have bigger problems. With all its hatred of Islam and Muslims, the US government still is careful of the law in their country.

But as far as that guy converting to Islam, well, very good for him. May he achieve peace and belief.

Re: Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees

Ab un nations k leaders yahan k leaders se ziada paak saaf toh hain nahin. Why would they want to get their hands dirty.

Re: Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees

If I was Iran I'd take him. :)

Re: Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees

^^

And that is why you are not Iran :D

Re: Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees

Atleast some sort of the judicial system is working fine. Hope the US does not take the extreme step of extra judicial killings to silence the more vehement of the GBay protestors...

Re: Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees

Making that comparison in this context is in really poor taste. The whole 'Muslim A did XYZ to Muslim B so now Muslim C shouldn't be complaining' is such piece of cra p.

the bolded part was sufficient. Truth of the matter is this is unfair by our own rule of law. Whether these people are Muslim is much less significant - they are captured falsely as you put it so nicely.

Re: Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees

Yes, but as Americans, there is a higher standard to uphold then some two bit dictator.

Re: Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees

They may have been captured on good pretext, but the proper term is they were falsely detained. They should have been given a fair trial within a few months of their capture and released. But if you watch the videos above it is clear the Gitmo detainees were/are being used as test rats ... There is a scientific process of interrogation black ops style and they are studying the results.

And the reason why the UK won't take back even innocent detainees, is because they know there is a strong chance that whatever happened to them while in custody will result in their own investigation or those people would have been converted in to radically minded people for being singled out when they were innocent.

Re: Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees

agreed.

Re: Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees


this is a very important point. the fact that gitmo remains a domestic controversy in the post-9/11 era is a testament to that higher standard. from a detainee treatment perspective, gitmo is a five-star resort compared to the vast majority of prison facilities in the third world let alone those housing enemy combatants/militants. modern terrorism is a test of american democracy and has introduced significant gray area into the system. what to do with gitmo detainees and the killing of enemy US citizens like awlaki without trial are examples of the dilemma facing the world's most advanced criminal justice system. damned if you do, damned if you don't. this doesn't mean we should accept degradation of fundamental american principals and blindly accept facilities like gitmo but it's important to acknowledge that there are no obvious right answers.

while it's true that lofty US civil liberty and criminal justice standards are being challenged, only those muslims who are legitimate champions of human rights in all countries for detainees of all religions should be protesting gitmo. the mind-boggling hypocrisy is what nobody will take seriously...people who support barbarians like the taliban crying about gitmo are all too common. there's no shortage of such jokers on this forum.

Re: Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees

For every 10 things that U.S. has going for it to earn it praise, it does a few things every once in a while that flush all that PR down the drain. Gitmo, Bagram, etc.

It should be closed down. Those whose cases have been heard and a outcome decided should be implemented. Free the ones that are eligible to be free. If their home country doesn't take them, be the Moral Symbol and give them residency here, it's the price you pay for wrongfully convicting someone and dragging them half way around the world to the point that their home nation won't want to take them back. Or find them residency in a country that will host them.

Those whose cases are still ongoing should be tried in Terrorism courts/Federal Courts on U.S. Soil in a transparent manner. G.W. era should come to a close now. Enough damage has been done all around.

Re: Guantanamo guard converts to Islam, demands release of detainees

^
freedom and democracy