In 1998 Mike Godwin made a sarcastic observation, it states “As an online discussion grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving Nazis or Hitler approaches 1”
So far this statement stands correct for most online discussions on numerous forums EXCEPT for our DESI discussion boards. For our desi boards I present Xeno’s Law.. here it goes
“As an online desi discussion grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving Indians or MQM or Pakistanis approaches 1”
PS:- I have this feeling that this thread will turn into a self-fulfilling prophecy pretty soon.
Arleitter, THAT is the point.. it doesn’t matter if it is relevant or not, it WILL somehow come into picture. Same as in any topic about a country’s internal affairs, India or Pakistan WILL come in to picture. This is how our pet love-hate relationship works.
I agree, this whole Ew-Pakistani vs. Ew-Indians is inevitable. But on the same hand, a decent and intellectual online discussion seems rather impossible to go on for a long period of time.
So I present to you Blacko’s Law:
As an online discussion grows longer, the probability of quickened degeneration of a discussion approaches 1".
***I would agree with the basic concept of the Law however I would take it further that on a desi forum such as this an intellectual online discussion seems highly improbable for a long time without it turning into a character assassination .
I present Sheyn’s Law
As an online desi discussion grows longer, the probability of it invariably turning into a character assassination approaches 1".***
^ Just in case you missed the point. The Godwin law IS about “NON-DESI” discussion forums. It’s a sarcastic observation pointing out the meaningless & throwing petty accusations IN “non-desi” online discussions. In our desi-forums, we don’t discuss Holocaust or Nazis, but we do have our own targets. I hope you can see the parallels here.
I question the authenticity of OP’s assertion that Godwin’s law, which concerns online discussion forums, was formulated in 1989. I base my observation on the fact that no such forums existed in 1989. :einstein_wali_smiley: