Ghost Schools In Sindh : Childern of Sindh have no luck

Society Pakistan & World Affairs
1

The documentary shows several ghost village schools in Mirpur Mathelo, Dadu, Obaro, and Badin, where the school buildings that are serving other purposes and for education. It is said there are now 5,000 such ghost schools. These schools exist on paper only as supposedly all teachers and other staff are receiving their salaries; the repair budget is being regularly spent in maintaining buildings; and students are being shown to be receiving education. But, in fact, no student is receiving any education at such schools.

The irony is that some of the schools reviewed in documentary are said to be in the villages where once families of many current and past ministers lived. The documentary mentions a school in the village of Pir Illahi Bux, who is the grandfather of current Sindh education Minister that has been closed for last nine years. A school village in the village of former Minister converted to a warehouse, and yet another school in the arae is in personal use of a wadera (feudal).

We have just become helpless bys tanders watching this tragedy that unfolds in front of our eyes. Something has to be done, something must be done before generations of Sindhi boys and girls go without education. – (Khalid Hashmani, McLean, Virginia)

Before commenting just watch the video.

Very sad & Pathetic :nahi: We should stop this corruption.

2

Re: Ghost Schools In Sindh : Childern of Sindh have no luck

Let me tell you what happened in last PAC meeting called over this issue .

I totally agree with the sindh education minister , Mr memon on this issue , at last PAC meeting , He said '' We have also asked government to let Sindh follow the same education system as the Punjab by dividing the department into three sections with separate secretaries.”

The accounting watchdog suggested that the department should avoid frequent teacher transfers by fixing a minimum two-year term for them at a school. There are serious flaws in the system - Ghost schools, overcrowding teachers in single schools are issues we have to deal with.

The current system gave the education officer the authority to give 300 to 400 teachers their monthly salaries without checking up on them. And this needed to be monitor .

The PAC chairman suggested that the department stop paying salaries at ghost schools. But this cannot be done because the department did not have the power.

The PAC also expressed concern over irregularities from 2006 to 2009. According to DG Audit - an education official had transferred around Rs93 million to different institutions - in 2008 without approval.

The education secretary claimed that the Rs16 million spent on buying stationery was faked by an official from his department and he had been transferred. :)

3

Re: Ghost Schools In Sindh : Childern of Sindh have no luck

Exactly and I watched a TV show and forgetting the name, i think Mubashir Luqman in which he was giving proofs for fake teachers who are getting double salaries.
So I mean first they should try to control this corruption and then ask for more money. Because that money ll be directly going to pockets of Politicians and their friends pockets.

4

Re: Ghost Schools In Sindh : Childern of Sindh have no luck

Nadra identifies 2,007 ghost schools costing Rs7 billion

In a startling disclosure, a latest verification by National Database and Registration Authority (Nadra) identified 2,007 ghost schools in four provinces fraudulently being run under a project Basic Education Community School (BECS) costing Rs7 billion, sources told this scribe here on Wednesday.

Sources said National Education Foundation (NEF) that introduced BECS project decided to contact Nadra for verification of NIC of the teaching and administrative staff members associated with these schools on July 27th, 2011.

“The report now presented by Nadra showed that names and NIC of officials working with 2,007 BECS schools are fake that raised the question how many people were involved in this illegal act and how much money they managed to secure on fake information out of total Rs4.5 billion so far spent on this project,” sources said.

An official said given the grave situation Board of Governors (BoG) of NEF in its meeting held on March 12 has decided to close down all these ghost schools but surprisingly it was not decided to probe this scam involving billions of rupees.

He said it was also decided in the meeting to restructure internal audit mechanism and six regional offices at Lahore, Multan, Karachi, Peshawar, Quetta and Gilgit would be established to serve this purpose.

According to official data, a total of Rs22 million were allocated to monitor BECS schools across the country and for this purpose some 130 non-governmental organisations (NGOs) were also involved to monitor 3,000 BECS schools in Punjab, 58 NGOs to monitor 2,655 schools in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa, 13 NGOs to monitor 259 schools in Balochistan and 40% of total 1,100 schools were also monitored by NGOs in Sindh.

An FIA official, who is working with its anti-corruption branch, told this correspondent that an investigation into a scam involving millions of rupees against one of the top BECS officials have been referred to National Accountability Bureau (NAB) on December 12 last year.

NEF Managing Director Nasir Hayat said that the report sent by Nadra showed 2,007 ghost schools and soon after receiving this report BoG of NEF has ordered to close down all these schools.

To a question, he said that the BoG at the moment has not ordered any inquiry into this scam but “I have personally made a request to thoroughly probe this issue as it has earned a bad name for our organisation.”

Talking to this correspondent, Federal Minister for Professional and Technical Training Riaz Hussain Pirzada said that the latest report has pointed out weak monitoring system so, “We have decided to introduce a new monitoring mechanism and agreements with all such NGOs that showed poor performance with regard to monitoring of BECS schools would be cancelled.”

He said many irregularities and corruption cases have been brought to his notice, adding, “I assure that thorough investigation would be conducted to identify those involved in running ghost schools.”

Riaz Pirzada said the BECS schools have high importance especially in far-flung areas and new measures would help improve their educational standard and administrative affairs as well

Nadra identifies 2,007 ghost schools costing Rs7 billion - thenews.com.pk

5

Re: Ghost Schools In Sindh : Childern of Sindh have no luck