You decide.
http://www.powersurgedesigns.com/video/
(Sorry i tried to upload it but it wont let me.)
BMW out performed camaro but driver also played a big role in it.. but the anti-climax was the BMW breaking down ....
Pound for pound the M3 destroyed the LS1’s 350HP with only 240HP. The little M3 engine is way too efficient and well tuned. Handling wise the Camaro got raped by the BMW too.
The best part was that baldie cop got OWNED by a 15 years old. 
hehe:
I have no doubt a decent driver would have lost the cop.
I doubt the m3 broke down either. I think it prolly ran out of gas.