bella88
September 2, 2014, 9:53pm
44
Re: From Atheism To Islam
Exactly … You are right … So without hearing the argument if one says that claim of Islam is a lie … They can only say that if they themselves had witnessed the opposite being true … Or else their own accusation backfires.
Now for me to support my argument to satisfy me … is going to be different to what you will need to be satisfied … If I read a statement in Hadith about this … For me this enough proof. So I make that claim out of the proof that my scripture says so … But since you are yet to accept my scripture I can’t possibly use that evidence to convince you of the same … However, what you can understand clearly is that I have not lied … You simply do not accept my evidence … The reverse however is not so clear as to how you arrived at the idea that the notion that all nations were sent prophets (AS) is false …
In order to satisfy we will need to reach some agreement on criteria … So what will be a good piece of evidence that suggests to you all nations were sent prophets of God … .???
you cannot give any evidence because there is none to back your claim. your faith is based on belief, not evidence. And yes, you’re right hadith is absolutely not an evidence