From Meluhha To Pakistan: The Embodiment Of A Civilization

[gsingh1984]

Re: From Meluhha To Pakistan: The Embodiment Of A Civilization

@Tinu

What I still do not understand is that why would the Indians continue to believe the Indus Valley Civilization was Indian Civilization when the core of this civilization is in Pakistan and a large majority of Pakistanis are the same people.

Because they are not so easily divided. You’re still an Indian, a bharati the government of India today is the worst enemy India has ever had. So end of the rubbish.

@Tinu

The most interesting thing in all this is that JM Kenoyer also states that Vedic culture evolved after 1500 BC and he also says that the IVC started declining after 1900 BC. How can he relate the artifacts of an earlier era with what evolved hundreds or even thousands of years later. You can not say that because Vedic Hindus followed polytheism in 1000 BC, the people of IVC would have followed the 3000 years earlier - such a thinking amounts to a misnomer and is manipulative. His speculations have been countered effectively by Dr. Dani, who excavated at Mohenjodaro and have clearly stated that IVC is a Pakistani civilization and have also qualified that its .

Vedic culture is much older, 1500bc claims some aryan invasion thing. I’ll just not even get into scientific evidence against that but simple common sense; since half of pakistan lives in Punjab, I’ll assume you’re Punjabi.

If the other myth about Bharat that of an extended Muslim(arab,turk,persian aka foreign) empire has been disproven how would these nomads displace us?

It took ghazni 17 raids to gain a fraction of a foothold against mere levies, which means pind vale bunde with w.e they had on them vs the best trained armies in the world at the time.

It took arabs 70 years to grab city of Makaran for barely a year when they conquered half the world in 8. There were multiple periods where no foreigners dared to invade due to the kabul and punjabi princes being sher. Many poets who wrote in Arabic who still have preserved manuscripts lamented how their empires went to drown in the Sindh and Ganges.

So, again how would would koray riding goray who were illiterate step to us?

17 or 18 times is no joke. Think about trying something that many times, and still being half-successful at the point you’re a tryhard. \

–
The whole IVC vs Vedic thing is a propaganda attempt. Main reason as Vedas are more associated with Sarasvati which runs a bit south aka ‘India’ and we know where Sindhu is.

Dr. Satinder Singh Noor and many tamil and telugu scholars as well agree that Punjabi is the world’s oldest language. Sanskrit and all the made up caste garbage come after.

–
Simple fact is, these are our ancestors, accept them, love them, worship them if that’s your way; but most of all, don’t ever let their lands fall into foreign hands.

IVC is a Pakistani civilization truth is IVC and Vedic are both pretty much Punjabi civilizations vedic tongue is closer to Punjabi than to sanskrit and I’m even surprised at how similar it sounds. It sounds like garbled Punjabi.
So let’s not get divided by two-nation trash, it’s called India after the Indus.

Any Pakistani that doesn’t recognize it as a Punjabi nation is lying to themself, others will tell you; someone was showing me how 49 out of 53 cm and sect. are from punjab and all this other stuff. However, I feel I’ve said too much on the forum today, and I have to run. I’m not from ‘Pakistan’ and if I was from Lehnda Punjab I would call myself that first anyway.

VJKVJF