From Meluhha To Pakistan: The Embodiment Of A Civilization

Tinu · April 2, 2013, 6:26pm

Re: From Meluhha To Pakistan: The Embodiment Of A Civilization

I Am trying to understand the psychology here

your whole claim relies on one flimsy assumption - the people the sumerians called the meluhha are the people of the indus valley.

now, this assumption’s validity relies 100% on the use of dravidian language correlation with loan words in sumerian, to refer to things like sesame seed. which are foreign to sumeria, and hence the words are non-native.

after all this, if you claim no, the indus valley wasn’t dravidian, it removes your first assumption - those that are refered to as the meluhha are the people of the indus.

and this is your agenda. say this to any anthropologist familiar with the peopling of the indian subcontinent and you will be laughed at.

the population in the indo-gangetic plains had already stabilized genetically, turkey had huge population changes afterwards. you are trying to say a 10 yr old kid is the father of a 60 yr old.

Oh come one - what crap are you referring to - the language of people of Indus Valley Civilization has not been deciphered as yet to comment whether it had any link with Dravidian or any other language for that matter.

The genetic studies that I refer to have not been conducted by me. These have been conducted by experts and they have written their findings and conclusions and these are available on the internet for you to read and find out the reality as it exists. I do not know or do not have the privilege to post graphics, otherwise I would have posted a genetic map of people of Indian and Pakistan for you to see and gauge for yourself.

Please study the genetic format of India and Pakistan first to comment any further. You are merely embarrassing yourself by posting shallow and uninformed responses.