French imams rail against 'crazies who have seized our religion'

I guess this sums yp dilemma for Muslims in EU. “Muslims are caught in a trap, between those who kill in the name of Islam and those who are using this to stigmatise Muslims,”

French imams rail against ‘crazies who have seized our religion’

Paris (AFP) - French imams condemned violence committed in the name of Islam during Friday prayers as the country reeled from the double hostage dramas that followed the massacre at Charlie Hebdo magazine.

“We denounce the odious crimes committed by the terrorists, whose criminal action endangers our willingness to live together,” said the rector of the Grand Mosque of Paris, Dalil Boubakeur.

He also appealed to “all the Muslims of France” to take part in demonstrations planned for Sunday to pay homage to the 12 victims of the attack on Charlie Hebdo on Wednesday, the bloodiest in France in more than half a century.

In local mosques across the country, imams condemned the jihadists who claimed they were avenging the Prophet Mohammed by shooting dead some of France’s best-known cartoonists at the satirical weekly.

Charlie Hebdo had angered many Muslims by repeatedly publishing cartoons that featured the Prophet as it lampooned Islamist extremists.

View galleryHead of France’s Muslim Council and rector of Paris’ …
Head of France’s Muslim Council and rector of Paris’ Grand Mosque Dalil Boubakeur gives a sp …
Muslim groups had taken the magazine to court over the drawings but had lost.

“The people who carried out that attack in the name of Islam are not Muslims… The Prophet did not advocate violence against non-Muslims,” Abdel Qader Achour, of the conservative Omar Ibn Al Khattab mosque not far from Charlie Hebdo’s offices, insisted.

“France is our country, we have been here for three or even four generations, and we should not be afraid,” he said as around one thousand of the faithful gathered to pray.

“To a cartoon you reply with a cartoon, to a drawing with a drawing, to a newspaper article with a newspaper article… But you don’t reply with guns,” said Mustafa Riad of the Union mosque in the southern city of Montpellier.

Muslim theologian Tareq Oubrou, an imam in Bordeaux, in the southwest, said Muslims were furious that their religion had been “confiscated by crazies… and uneducated, unbalanced people”.

View gallery"Paris est Charlie" (Paris is Charlie) is …
“Paris est Charlie” (Paris is Charlie) is projected onto the Arc de Triomphe in Paris, on …

  • Fear of rise in hostility -

Muslim leaders fear that the Charlie Hebdo attack will lead to further hostility and attacks against their community.

Prime Minister Manuel Valls insisted Friday that France was “in a war against terrorism”, but not “against a religion”, and President Francois Hollande appealed for a halt to emotive rhetoric and “stigmatisation and sorry caricaturing” of others.

Since Wednesday’s attack, shot have been fired and grenades thrown at several Muslim places of worship without causing injuries.

Four shots were fired at the front of a mosque in Albi in the south and racists slogans scrawled on another in Bayonne in the southwest. On Friday a pig’s head and its entrails were found hanging from the door to a prayer hall in Corte on the island of Corsica.

“I am afraid that their acts will get worse in the coming days,” said Abdallah Zekr, the president of the French Muslim Council (CFCM), which monitors Islamophobic attacks.

“Muslims are caught in a trap, between those who kill in the name of Islam and those who are using this to stigmatise Muslims,” he said.

Up to 390 French jihadists are thought to be fighting in Syria, according to the latest estimates, and around 60 have died fighting with extremist groups there.

Muslim Amine Guellil, a 47-year-old estate agent, said: “A good Muslim would never shoot anyone, those who do that cannot be Muslims.”

Two of the victims of the Charlie Hebdo massacre were Muslims, with policeman Ahmed Merabet shot in cold blood as he tried to stop the terrorists fleeing the seen, he said.

“There are several million Muslims in France, and the vast majority are integrated into French society,” said Claude Dargent, a professor at Sciences Po university in Paris. “And for those who aren’t, it’s less a question of religion than their social and economic situation.”

Re: French imams rail against 'crazies who have seized our religion'

The elephant in the room will never be adressed.

Why are these cartoons drawn in the first place.

When someone makes a cartoon on stoning or beheading, why is he doing that? Because someone is carrying out these punishments, or because many muslims refuse to renounce these punishments as barbaric?

Part of the reason why Islamophobia is on rise in Europe, is because many muslim ulema in Europe refuse to take a clear cut stance against barbarity.

Yeah stoning women is fine, as long as you follow the rules. Capital punishment for apostasy is fine, but their are certain rules. Hit women, but lightly. And so on.

If they said these things are barbaric and wrong, full stop. Then made this the prevalent mindset, they would do muslims in Europe a huge favour. Leave no room for ambiguity, just say its wrong.

Obviously , You don't even need religion to discuss these issues in the first place. The very fact that religion encompasses all aspects of life, has lead to a lot of failure in muslim nations. But the solution for that seems to be even more religious interference in worldly matters.

Use religion to solve matters of spirituality, use worldly knowledge to solve worldly matters. Formula works for western europe, why are muslims in western europe hesitant to adopt it?

Re: French imams rail against 'crazies who have seized our religion'

Sums it up well

"Muslims are caught in a trap, between those who kill in the name of Islam and those who are using this to stigmatise Muslims," he said.