If a person commits murder or zinnah.. why is the person punished for it when it happened by the will/instructions of Allah?
Re: Prove to me that there is not Allah
with that logic, we should never warn or ban anyone on GS anymore, cause every single word on gs is written with will of Allah
It's a question TLK Bhai.. when everything has already been written by Allah swt, why is the person (catalyst) punished and blamed for it? Why isn't he pardoned as it was Allah's will?
When a loved one dies people say "It's Allah's will" if a person commits zinnah who's will is it?
It's a question TLK Bhai.. when everything has already been written by Allah swt, why is the person (catalyst) punished and blamed for it? Why isn't he pardoned as it was Allah's will?
When a loved one dies people say "It's Allah's will"
See we make the biggest mistake when we try to understand Allah's as a human.(allah as human like thing)
See allah never said that he is a big man making decisions every day after looking every one's case.
He gave us glimpse about him and universe around us. As he said when he wants some thing done "kun fa yakoon" (he say happen ---and it does happen)
No machinery no labours. Then about universe how time and space has different meaning at different points of universe. How ppl can be taken out of these terms(ones we call world-- one we are familiar with) and can be left in different terms..and while being there if we remember earth we would be surprised to see how time/space gets different meaning(mentioned dozens of time in quran)
Thing I am trying to say is, We are a smallest part of his creation. Our brain can perceive like half a dimension.. our terms/condition/environment(constants) are just a littlest part of the whole big picture.
How do we expect to understand an entity who actually created it??
You know It all comes down to faith.. We all know(ppl with half decent brains) that its the truth....
So just have faith..
Allah's will and his knowledge of future often gets mixed up. Time passes for us. We go through it point by point... I mean allah created time... he is out of it.. so our "future" is not so much future for him.. its there for him to see...
BUT its us who shape the future its in our hands... as prophet said..
if it was in the hand of a human, he/she would never want to die. Because its not in our hands, hence we say its Allah's will. As long as we are living, we have the choices to make. Allah has given us the options.. committing zinnah is something in ur control, while dying can never be.
But I committed zinnah because it was written by Allah... what if that's what the person replies back with?
Re: Prove to me that there is not Allah
^Allah has given you free will. You are not farishta who have specific duties to do and they offer their duties. You are Ashraful Makhlooqat. You cannot say that Allah has written everything before hand. If that is the case then another question arises what is the point of making us?