Re: For they are created from a bent rib
AQ what is your point? dont shirk away from the discussion simply by being inconclusive.
sadiyah, the most relevant Shia perspective on this was already posted by PCG at the beginning of the thread. I'll get home tonight and see if I can find direct references from our books on this issue, i got these two references from a shia bbs system that i cant directly quote here.
regarding your second point, the hadees e kissa, one of the most widely read ahadith in shia Islam is sourced, amongst others, to bibi Ayesha. regardless of what goes on amongst majalis, much of which might not be correct in the shia school of thought, we have a lot of ahadees quoted from sahaba, including bibi ayesha.
to be honest, the usual thought process of the typical shia (including me) is to accept sunni ahadith that agree with a shia interpretation of the religion, and reject ones that conflict with it, as untrustworthy. I guess people better versed in history follow a more rigorous process, i honestly dont.