For people who are interested in Hadith topic.

[Mr.Popat]

@submitmj

I understand what you are telling me, but hadith came from Bukhari, not the prophet. The QUran came from Muhammad. GOD put a miracle in the Quran to confirm it is the unaltered word of GOD. So, we KNOW every word of it is the absolute truth and cannot be abrogated.

As well, you pointed out the verse, ‘Had he issued any other teachings, we would have punished him. We would have stopped the revelations to him’. So, if there are teachings in hadith that are contradictory to the QUran (which there are), and are confirmed to be 'AUTHENTIC" hadith. That would mean prophet Muhammad DID preach other teachings. Therefore, the Quran would not be complete and fully detailed, which it is. The great math miracle confirms it is completed. So, by default, Muhammad NEVER issued other teachings, meaning the ‘authentic’ hadiths COULD NOT HAVE COME FROM Muhammad. They simply could not have.

As well, the word ‘hadith’ means ‘narration’. The Quran is a first-person narration from GOD to us through His messenger. Hadith & Sunnah are ‘third party’ narrations CLAIMED to be from the prophet. So, a narration from the GOD directly through HIS messenger is to be obeyed. A narration through a chain of unauthorized humans claiming to be from the prophet 200+ years after he died IS NOT a narration from GOD (Quran). It is ‘other teachings’ by men (Bukhari etc.).

The bottom line is if Muslims truly love and respect the prophet, they would follow what he followed. The Quran. It is as simple as that.

Peace

This is what i said, if a hadith is taken as authentic and it contradicts Quran, then chances are its not authentic.. its very simple. Beside, there are many things in Qur’an which commands Muslim to act but simply do not guide Muslims how to. Hajj , Namaaz, Fasting are some of the many examples which are fardh on us in Qur’an but we will only be doing it according to however we please, unless we follow what MuhammadPBUH used to do in His times.

It is written in Qur’an alone that it is the book of Allah. It’s like me giving u a book and telling you that every single word in it is an absolute truth because i wrote that in the book that its absolute truth.

If you just follow Qur’an , it will be like respecting the pages of Quran but giving no respect to the person on whom this book was revealed on.

You failed to explain the miracles God put in the Quran which tells u its the book of God. Please explain

I am not here to justify ahadith, for sure, there are ahadith which are there in the books which i wouldnt say is incorrect, but passed down in different meaning and hence got a total new meaning of it, which contradicts quran , hence, not authentic.

Then there are ahadith which are being fulfilled even to this date. If someone calls one hadith weak or not authentic and it somehow happens, then my friend, it is not the hadith thats weak , its your heart that weak to accept it. People in the past have organized ahadith based on which is authentic and which isnt, but if say a hadith that is categorized as unauthentic happens to happen, then we have NO CHOICE but to accept that it must have been the word of MuhammadPBUH ( given that its in accordance with that teaching of Quran).