And I am criticizing his personal reaction and the actions taken as a result of his personal thought process. Not as illegal, but still shameful.
Twice to ansar abbasi. Not regular by my count.
it would be nice if you always had the option of getting them killed eh?
Thanks.
I previously mentioned we might have different historical basis. This probably wouldnt be in mine. Even so I wouldnt say the only reason was blasphemy. Heres a fuller description of the circumstances:
According to Ibn Ishaq, Muhammad called upon his followers to kill Ka’b because the latter “had gone to Mecca after Badr and provoked Quraysh to fight the prophet. He also composed verses in which he bewailed the victims of Quraysh who had been killed at Badr. Shortly afterwards he returned to Medina and composed amatory verses of an insulting nature about the Muslim women.”[3] Other historiographical sources state that the reason for killing of Ka’b was that he had plotted with a group of Jews to kill Muhammad. The writings of the later commentators such as al-Zamakhshari, al-Tabarsi, al-Razi and al-Baydawi provide another distinct report according to which Ka’b was killed because Gabriel had informed Muhammad about a treaty signed by himself and Aba Sufyan creating an alliance between the Quraysh and forty Jews against Muhammad during Ka’b’s visit to Mecca (According to Professor Uri Rubin, some allusions to the existence of an anti-Muhammadan treaty between Quraysh and Ibn al-Ashraf may be found in the earlier sources).
Ka’b ibn al-Ashraf - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Far from being someone who said some casual poetry.
I dont believe death penalty was given besides this case, and in atleast one named instance (although the munafiqeen were a known group of people) no action was taken against the people.
I do not care if the laws of the western countries do change as a result. i am not worried about consequences, I am concerned with what is right and what is wrong. Whether we have the moral right to begin with, to ask for freedom of religious expression.
Total non-sequitor. Freedom of speech does not equate with no capital punishment.
Then you should agree that Muslims shouldnt expect openended religious freedom elsewhere.
You do not decide what is offensive to another. In Pakistan people have been killed for saying things like “Your prophet married an 8 year old”. To someone that might be a statement of fact, just as for us saying a cow is just an animal is. How about eating beef? Currently Muslims are allowed to do that, on the basis of religious freedom, despite objections of Hindu hardliners. Do you side with the BJP on this? Would you like Muslims killed for such offenses?
You should. Being emotional may be an excuse it is not a justification.
What you call stupid another calls religion, and vice-versa.
So, if you were outside Pakistan (i dont know if you currently are) and recieved such an email, what would you do? You cant get the person killed, and according to you the appropriate reaction is indeed that. Would you kill him yourself?