FIA arrests person for expressing blasphemous thoughts to Ansar Abbasi

I believe these two points are connected. The breach of privacy issue is not applicable. If authorities have a clear evidence of someone breaking a law they are authorised to ascertain further evidence. In either we donot know whether or not the authorities went through regular channel to pursue the identity of a the blasphemer. You are objecting to a religious law so inavriably religion forms the basis of argument.

no actually the two incidents are quite different in nature. Since we donot know the entire content of the email the comparison would be futile.

But the punishment in itself changed so we are arguing how should blasphemous acts should be tackled with .

I brought this one up to show that punishment and conducts towards munafiqeen has chagned. Not as an example of uniform nature of crime or punishment.

Actually shia religion also has very strict ruling about blasphemy. Khomeinin infamous fatwa about rushdi in 1989 and recent confirmation of its validity Death fatwa against Rushdie still valid, says Iran. So being a shia doesnot change the nature of punishment in regards to blasphemy. How you conclude it to be a private conversation is beyond me. The email was written to a journalist, the journalist in question found something breaching the pakistanis law, he then took it upon himself to report it. Nothing can reasonable provide legal grounds to ignore it. How can you possibly ascertain that the authorities involved didnot get a legal go ahead to pursue the identity of blasphmer?

i didnt assume , you yourself said that i donot know much about history. In any case can you give the background religious information to condemn a law that has its basis in religion. Until then i am afraid i will continue with my aalim knows the best approach.

a)Regardless of the population abroad a coutnry forms its consitution to serve the interests and represent the populaiton in it. I donot see saudis hiding for cover and they are governed by much more stricter laws then Pakistanis.

b) Pakistanis abroad have every right to expect to be treated as per the law of the country they are residing in. I doubt any country changes their laws and rules to better accomodates pakistanis. So i would expect a secular govt to treat me by its standarads. In any case i wouldnot redicule the prophets of christianity since that is blasphemy as per my believes regardless of the law of land. So yes i donot mind if western govt enforce a law where disrespecting their reliigous icons is a punishable offence.