Fate of Muslims in India.

This is an eye opener, althoigh obviously the fate of our brothers is well known to us.

http://www.soundvision.com/info/india/profile.asp


Profile of Muslims in India
Overall, the Muslims of India make up 12 percent of the country’s population of over one billion. Islam is India’s largest minority religion.

India’s Muslim communities tend to be more urban than rural. In many towns and cities in northern India, Muslims are one-third or more of the population. The largest concentrations of Muslims, about 52 percent, live in the states of Bihar (12 million), West Bengal (16 million), and Uttar Pradesh (24 million), according to the country’s 1991 census.

India’s Muslims have played a historic role in shaping Indian society, particularly in the medieval period in the areas of architecture, calligraphy, miniature paintings, handicrafts, handloom, music, poetry, literature in mystic humanism, culinary arts and sartorial fashions.

Not only does the Taj Mahal, the most famous symbol of India, commemorate the love for a Muslim queen, but the very name India is an Anglicized version of the Arabic name Hind which Muslim scholars started using for the area beyond Sindh (roughly the east of Pakistan today).

The Indian Constitution claims to provide equality of opportunity to all individuals, organizations and social groups. But the biggest Indian minority is a victim of deprivation. Whether it is legislative assemblies educational institutions, government jobs, the problem of security in case of riots, representation in political organizations, posts in policy planning and decision-making groups or other pressure groups there is acute shortage of Muslim representation everywhere, resulting in constant social tension and problems in governance.

Some challenges the Indian Muslims face:

  1. Communal riots against Muslims are among the biggest tragedies of this independent, secular democracy. Wherever Muslims have acquired a relatively better economic position, these riots send them back to the starting point. There have been 249 riots per year according to Indian government statistics. Senior Indian journalist, Khuswant Singh notes that in all communal violence that has taken place in India since Independence in the 1940s, over 75 per cent of the causalities - in terms of lives and property destroyed - were Muslim.

  2. The second important problem is the state of present textbooks in the Indian education system which have become very aggressive in teaching Hinduism. This hits Muslims’ faith, culture, civilization, language and way of life. The educational syllabi have prescribed course books in all states, which are replete with matters pertaining to the faiths of the majority community, mythological and other stories of Hindu gods and goddesses against the principles prescribed in the Constitution. Obviously all these things are negations of Islamic beliefs and teachings, especially about the Oneness of God Almighty. Hence there is no doubt that these things are causing great concern to the Muslims.

The rewriting of history is done in a way that continues to fuel the non-secular, chauvinistic Hindu perspectives, causing the new generation of Indians to shape their behavior towards minorities in a very hostile way.

  1. The economic problem: More than fifty percent Muslims are leading a life below the poverty line as compared to thirty-five percent of Hindus who live below the poverty line. Because of a general environment of hostility against Muslims, decent employment in the private sector is becoming increasingly difficult for Muslims, while in the public sector there is no encouragement for Muslims either. The future of Muslim professionals and its working class, traders etc has been very greatly affected.

Today very few Muslims are found in government jobs. A recent survey shows that there are only eight Muslim police chiefs in India’s 591 districts. That is .01% as compared to 12% of the Muslim population in India. The situation of other departments is also worsening day by day.

  1. Education: The active discrimination Muslims face in the private and public sector of the job market, has forced them to pay less attention to school education which, in India, is connected with the job market. In the educational field therefore, Muslims are very backwards.

  2. Urdu language. Another major problem of Muslims of India is that of the Urdu language. The Urdu language was born as a result of the interaction and cohesion of different languages, nations, cultures and civilizations and is a mixture of some old languages like Sanskrit, Arabic, Persian, Turkish etc. Urdu is almost a dead language now as far as the medium of instruction is concerned. It is not tolerated even in the primary and secondary stages of education.

The Muslims of India are very vulnerable in a country which describes itself as the world’s “largest secular democracy”. Muslims today remain poorer, less educated and less empowered in India.


Mo: You are a smart boy. Stop reading articles written by 9 yr olds. Nice source :rolleyes:

The above analysis is incredibly simplistic. It seems to be written from the view heard most often from pakistanis who a visceral dislike of hindus of India. The issue of what is the future of Islam is in India is no doubt very important. Muslims of India have not been denied access to India's educational system, and I suspect might have produced more highly qualified people in different fields than Pakistan and Bangladesh. One of the consequences of 1971 and the subsequent no-go areas in Karachi with Altaf being more or less guided by RAW, Indian Muslims (outside of Kashmir) stopped looking towards Pakistan to either provide support or to voice their needs and concerns. This has required the Indian Muslims to develop an Identity of their own independent of Pakistan and Bangladesh. That has been one of the most beneficial fallout of 1971 for India. In my judgement, although they are under stress from the hindus trying to find their own identity after nearly a 1000 years of rule by others, the long term progonosis looks pretty good. Their pattern probably resembles the closest to the development pattern of the muslims of Sri Lanka.

Fate and future of Muslims in india is beter than the Muslims living in pakistan.

Ask Muslims living in India if they would like to transfer to Pakistan, you will get reply!

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by anand: *
Fate and future of Muslims in india is beter than the Muslims living in pakistan.

Ask Muslims living in India if they would like to transfer to Pakistan, you will get reply!
[/QUOTE]

i agree with you indian muslims have their own identity not looking forward to pakistan or arabs to solve their problems.

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by rvikz: *

i agree with you indian muslims have their own identity not looking forward to pakistan or arabs to solve their problems.
[/QUOTE]

true indian muslims need to fight thier own battle

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by rvikz: *

i agree with you indian muslims have their own identity not looking forward to pakistan or arabs to solve their problems.
[/QUOTE]

rvikz Ji

Indian Muslims have their Indian Identity just as the Pakistani Hindus have a Pakistani Identity and the Bangladeshi Hindus have a Bangladeshi Identity.

Indian Muslims are as much a part of India and are Indian as Pakistani Hindus are a part of Pakistan and are Pakistanis and Bangladeshi Hindus are a part of Bangladesh and are Bangladeshis.

Have a nice day

what ever the source of the link ........but I have met a muslim indian , who said something pretaining to point # 3.

**3. The economic problem: More than fifty percent Muslims are leading a life below the poverty line as compared to thirty-five percent of Hindus who live below the poverty line. Because of a general environment of hostility against Muslims, decent employment in the private sector is becoming increasingly difficult for Muslims, while in the public sector there is no encouragement for Muslims either. The future of Muslim professionals and its working class, traders etc has been very greatly affected.

Today very few Muslims are found in government jobs. A recent survey shows that there are only eight Muslim police chiefs in India's 591 districts. That is .01% as compared to 12% of the Muslim population in India. The situation of other departments is also worsening day by day.**

He also mentioned that when muslims returned from HAJ they were discriminated at the airport by custom officers i.e after reading the names in their passports ....

Who is the author of this article, ….Profile of Muslims in India.?

Where Khuswant Singh has made such a statement about Muslims of India?

India is the only country where a minority community…in this case Muslims take equal part in riots, (only exception is Gujrat riots.)
Mosques are protected. India is a country where majority population Hindu cannot rebuild a temple. (Ram vs Babri).

Muslims are living below poverty line!
Is it a fault of Hindus if majority of convert Muslims are slum dwellers?

Does Indian history degrade the importance of medieval Muslim kings? What about Akabar the Great? This emperor is given all regards.

In Pakistan there is an army medal after ‘Aurangzeb’….what for, …..that he imprisoned his father and killed his brother, for capturing power.

Language problem…..no problem. In any country people have to qualify in the language of the majority, is a fact.
What is the position of Hindi in Pakistan?

In India, population of Muslims has increased as per ratio of Hindu population.
In Pakistan minorities curse their parents for giving them that land to live.

And yes, India is the largest secular democracy in the world, pls ask some Muslim minister in India! There are plenty of them.

^ Anand , Just ur attitude in the post shows how racist u r against muslims in general and indian muslims in particular.

India a ** democracy and secular. **

:rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl:

you cannot be serious! after what happened in gujerat and ahmendabad not forgetting ayodyha and these are recent events :frusty2:

how about bangaldesh muslims poverty who caused indian goverment?

even during mughal period muslims position were the same i mean the native born muslim as compared to foreign muslims. most of the muslims converted from poor section of hindu community to seek equality.

those who earned their living by "unclean tasks" (such as corpse-handling, tanning/leather work, or janitorial work) were often treated with disdain by both the Islamic and Hindu elite. The majority of the Islamic conquerors and ruling dynasties refrained from close social interaction and marriage with the local artisans and working castes just as much as did Brahmins or Kshatriyas.

The People wheather Muslim or Hindus are more protected in India than in any muslim country.

Hello?! Gujrat Riots ring any bells? :rolleyes:

Deleted<

Even when Gujarat was burning, practically the whole of India was at peace — that is the normal pattern here," said Syed Shahabuddin, editor of Muslim India, a monthly magazine, and a former Indian diplomat. “India is a democracy, and more than that, India is a secular democracy, at least in principle, and it does maintain a certain level of aspiration and hope for Muslims. . . . If there were no democracy in India, there would be chaos and anarchy, because so many different people are aspiring for their share of the cake.” It is precisely because of the “constitutional framework here,” added Mr. Shahabuddin, that Indian Muslims don’t have to resort to terrorism as a minority: “You can always ask for economic and political justice here.”
http://www.nytimes.com/2002/08/14/opinion/14FRIE.html