well you need to go back and read what you said.. and no what I said is not my opinion…what shias do is called a faqa, they dont do any neyat for fast.
so for what i said i feel comfortable, although to be more precise i would have to have said
" you dont fast, you fast, you fast a half day "
the statement is incoherent. the poor sister might have had to run to the drugs store for painkillers to consume such a statement
this halfday policy is also inline with the shiaism that i know, it fulfills the taqiyah requirements