Fasting on Ashura ..

[shardmanny]

Re: Fasting on Ashura ..

@Lusi

wow big claims over here dude! there is no such thing as half day fast, shias dont fast, they just dont eat anything until after asar namaz.

i dont think you have been reading attentively enough

i said:

every marja will give his own opinion however due to not having any set beliefs,

lets see opinions already expressed
opinion A

Briefly to explain the view and from what I know and have learned, the reason Shias don’t observe a full fast is because it is believed to have been written about the battle of Karbala that Yazids mother had promised to keep a fast

opinion B

sects questioning the source of this hadith and saying that this could be a potential ploy of the jews to get muslims to start celebrating rather then mourning the Karbala Tragedy

opinion C

there is no such thing as half day fast, shias dont fast,

opinion D

they just dont eat anything

youve got your feet in 2 out the 3 squares