Re: unparalleled ..... unparalleled .... unparalleled ....
My Bro Dawii-dill AOA
1)
Quran says do not appoint/consider jews and chrestians as ur wali/decision makers.
And u are still qouating from them. They including the historians u mentioned, writes history and when they do they look at their skills as a ruler not as a beleiver. So they admire him as fighter not as a good beleiver. The rank 52 defines him as an influential personality who brought change in the lives of a lot ( a QUANTITY) and islam teaches us of Quality ( may be ONE). history has few flaws and one of them " HISTORY IS ALWAYS WRITEN BY and WRITTEN FOR WINNERS" and is not always true. Usually carry bias in form of love or hate.
2) Proof should be from the scholars from both shia and sunni sources. Not just shia or sunni.
3) When we shia claim that abu sufian, mawiaa, and yazid had enimity with Prophet, Ali and Hussain respectively from the begining of Islam and sufian and mawia kept it till their death, u reject it and now u are telling same story for every one esle that iranis do not like arabs and so on.
4) U will get answer for ayaa(s) of quran soon from me for umar.
5) When u get an naswer, u usually rejects it by saying
a) he /she exagerates
b) his/her mother or father was shia
c) or he/she had(s) racism
6) try to develop a habit to read and then argue. Just go and read Mammon rasheed discussion with scholars of the time and u will find out. What about tafzeeli Ehli-sunnat.
7) Bravery of sahaba according to history can be found in any history book when all were fleeing and only few were there with prophet (pbuh) in badr.
8) only 6 ayaas thats all how many do u need for Ali (as) one, two, 10, 20 , 30 and so on. with proof from sunni scholars.
9) Umer himself said Ali (as) u are my imam/mulla/akaa with prooves from sunni books and never ali said the reversed.
10) Abu dar, mikdad and few others were killed, desserted or refrained from joining abu bakr or umar.
11) Ali always entered declaration/seletion/election/nomination process clearly to claim his right., With prooves from sunni scholars.
Suffice. Just go and read for ur self mamoon, do not just declare with out reading. It is logical disscussion among them with proofs from ayaas and ahadith. I my self like to read and have books from my own home from sunni scholars such as tahirul Qadri, Dr. Israr, Dr. Taha Hussain, Sahih Bhukari, Quran by Mudoodi and so on. So please go and read WITH OPEN EYES AND HEART ( unbiased )and then comment and make decision.
take care and Allaha Hafiz