Re: Famous Rewayet Of About Hz. Ali Ra.
Meray wahabi dost!
mainey is rawayat key baray main yaqeenan suna hai, lakin app key alfaaz ney rawyat ko kis kadar tabdeel kia; kia app ko is baat ka ehsaas hai ?
Alfaaz badal denay sey, ya khuch kum ker denay aur barha denay sey aik baaat ka poora matlab badal jata hai.
Mainey jo rawayat suni thi woh khuch is tarah thi
"One day a person came to Ali (Radi Allah Anhu). He was planning to ask Ali (Radi Allah Anhu) such a question which would take Ali (Radi Allah Anhu) a long time to answer and because of that his Maghrib Prayers would be delayed. He asked, 'Ali you say you know everything in the world, then tell me which animals lay eggs and which animals give birth to their young ones Hazrat Ali (Radi Allah Anhu) looked back at him smiled and said, ‘The animals who have their ‘EARS’ outside their body give birth to their young ones and the animals who have their ‘EARS’ inside their body lay eggs.’ "
Abb app key alfaaz
pehli baat to yeh key agar banday ney yeh poocha key** kitnay** janwaar anday detay hain ? or **kitnay **janwar bachay detay hain to Imam Ali ko ginti main jawab dena chahieye tha.
doosri baaat ka app ko pehlay hi ehsaas ho gaya hai, Jo rawayat mainey post ki hai or jo sunney main aam hai us key mutabiq Imam Ali a.s ney yeh nahi kaha key baghair kaan key janwaar anday detay hain aur jin key kaan hoon woh janwar bachay detay hain. App key alfaaaz key ghalat istamaal ney poori baat ka matlab hi tabdeel ker dia.
Back to topic,
mainey is waqaya ki source dhoondnay ki bhot koshish ki hai, lakin mujhey nahi mili. Agar app ko is rawayat ki koi source milay to please post karain.
Jis tarah sey app ney khud sey do chaar alfaaz add ker diey aur khud sey 2 chaar nikaal bahir diey issi tarah suni sunai kahnioon main aksar yeh masla hota hai key khuch ziada kam ker key matlab badal dia jata hai.
Mujhey pata hai app whale or doplhin ki baat karo gey key un key kaan andar hain lakin woh anday nahi bachay deti hain lakin Kia app ney yeh bhi soocha key aaya yeh Imam Ali key exact alfaaaz hain ( ‘The animals who have their ‘EARS’ outside their body give birth to their young ones and the animals who have their ‘EARS’ inside their body lay eggs.’). App kitnay yaqeen sey keh saktay hain key alfaaz exactly same hain ?
Imam Ali a.s ko Rasool pak s.a.w ilm key shehar ka darwaza kaha hai un key ilm per shak kerna munasib nahi.
App ko Bibi fatima a.s ka kisa to yaad hi ho ga, jab unhoon ney Hussnain a.s sey keh dia key tumharay kapray darzi key pass hain jab key un key kapray kisi darzi key pass nahi they. Bibi Pak ney sirf kaha aur un ki baat such ho gai. ajab nahi key Agar bibi pak subah ko raat kahain aur un key kehnay sey pehlay waqian raat ho jaey. Imam Ali ney yeh exact alfaaz kahay hotay to mera iman hey key yaqeenan whale anday dey rahi hoti.
dua hey key app ko meri baat thori bhot samjh aa hi gai ho gi
Wasalam
App ka shia dost
Aqeel