ex-Air Chief criticizes GOP Baloch policy

One of those people who was never afraid to speak his mind..Nur Khans comments are interesting..

By A Reporter

ISLAMABAD, May 14: Pakistan owes an apology to the people of Balochistan, FATA and those living in the interior of Sindh for letting development and progress bypass these people, sinking them deeper into the dungeon of poverty, sickness and ignorance, according to former air force chief Air Marshal Nur Khan.

Talking to Dawn over the weekend, he said the continuous neglect of the people of the largest province and the tribal areas had consigned them “to seemingly a bottomless pit of deprivation”.

“And the failure of successive governments to do away with the coercive laws like the Frontier Crimes Regulation in FATA and the continued adherence to Sardari system to rule Balochistan from Islamabad has made the people of these regions feel like aliens in their own country,” the Air Marshal added.

If these people put up armed resistance to attempts by the current government to establish its so-called ‘writ’ in these regions, **no one should feel surprised or betrayed because their peaceful protests have been continuously ignored all these years and they now know no other language, maintained Nur Khan **who served as deputy martial law administrator and as governor of the then West Pakistan during the military rule of Gen Yahya Khan in 1969.

The former air chief condemned the use of force by the government in Balochistan and FATA to establish its writ and termed the move as ill-advised and illegal. “As somebody said, if governments do not do all they can to honour non-violent resistance, then by default they privilege those who turn to violence,” he contended.

The Taliban phenomenon was also the product of continuous neglect and perpetual deprivation of the people of the tribal areas, he said, adding “people would certainly listen to those who preach violence in the name of religion if their peaceful pleas for due attention and assistance have fallen on deaf ears. And the use of massive fire power against these elements to subjugate them instead of engaging them through peaceful negotiations would only get a violent response which often degenerates into terrorism.”

“These regions are not war booties. The people of these regions joined Pakistan by their own consent and free will,” he said.

“They are as much masters of this country as any Pakistani. Therefore, their consent needs to be sought prior to any action the centre would take in their areas. You cannot establish your writ over your own people by military action. You need to have their consent for the purpose and the writ needs to be shared with them and not imposed on them by a military edict,” argued the Air Marshal.

He said the military mindset seemed to have made it impossible for the generals who were ruling the country today to understand the complexities of governance and how to deal with the opposition, both peaceful and violent.

He said it was improper on the part of the president to call the Sardars of Balochistan ‘pygmies’ and ‘miscreants’ and their resistance to the military action in their areas as mere ‘pin-pricks’.

“Instead of calling them names, they should be treated like honourable citizens of the country. If the democratic process in the country had not been halted by the army every 10 years and the political development had been allowed to continue without any let-up or hindrance any of these Sardars would have got elected to the offices of president, prime minister and provincial chief minister,” he added.

**“These are honourable and brave people and they are patriotic. I know all of them - Sardar Marri, Sardar Mengal and Sardar Bugti and the late Mir Bizenjo. I have dealt with them when I was governor of West Pakistan in 1969. They are very intelligent people and they are not secessionists. Even in their worst moments they would not contemplate hitching their fate and future with any foreign country. **Unfortunately my negotiations with them remained inconclusive because I had left the then martial law government in January 1970,” he added.

Nur Khan noted that Balochistan and FATA were still being ruled through the most primitive laws and rejected the Sardari system as too obscure to remain in vogue in the 21st century.

Re: ex-Air Chief criticizes GOP Baloch policy

He is right! We should have kicked out Sardari system back in the 50s. These Sardars are nothing but bunch of dynosaurs trying to be T-Rexes on their own people.

Yeap! We owe an apology to all Balochis and FATA people. Both Urdu People and Punjabis let these areas rot in the name of "protecting local culture" of jirga-ism and jingo-ism.

We should have sent in Army and its engineers to dynamite the mountains and build wide roads throughout FAT-FAT FATA and Balochistan's Kohlu disctrict.

This was the only way to rid the ancient cultures and their stranglehold on poor people of these areas.

Re: ex-Air Chief criticizes GOP Baloch policy

Air marshal Nur Khan should also acknowledge that for decades now it is impossible to have a free movement in FATA.

Construction companies have to hire "budaraga" ( the local protection) even when we want to send in an engineer for planning a new project.

If you tell this Pushtoon budaraga your itinerary a day ahead of time, he sends out the message, and the FAT FATA FATA criminals kidnap this poor engineer. Then the government has to give tawan (ransom money) to get the poor thing released.

So the lesson for the poor engineer is never to tell this brave Pushtoon badraga the exact travel time. You only wake him up 1 hour before it is time to leave. Then you have to do a mad dash through the survey area and run back out of FATA FATA for your life.

Then we have these Kabuli Kommies who love to f@rt on this forum that we don't do enough for the development of the area.

Bunch of be-ghairat munafiqeen.

Re: ex-Air Chief criticizes GOP Baloch policy

This govt (like previous govts) is only interested in filling their pockets and staying power.

Any challenge to them, they resort to the easy response of bombing them, while enjoying life in their mansions.

Re: ex-Air Chief criticizes GOP Baloch policy

Oh Baboo Khan! Let's talk mano a mano. For decades now, it has been really risky to send in engineering / surveying staff in tribal area.

These tribals kidnap company (and even government) officials and hold them for tawan (ransom).

It is almost like inviting death if a businessman ever ventures into tribal areas for any kind of investment. WHY?

Mantions are only possible if there is relative calm in the area. We can now send in teams of engineers in any area of Punjab, non-FATA Frontier and get the survey / installation completed on time on budget. Sure there may be few occasions of vandelism, or dacoities (looting). But overall you investment is much safer in Punjab compared to FATA or Balochistan.

Re: ex-Air Chief criticizes GOP Baloch policy

look who is so quick to bring in “Urdu people” to blame, you leave no opportunity in trashing “Urdu people” and Muslim-brother-hood :hoonh:

Re: ex-Air Chief criticizes GOP Baloch policy

Chaand Mian! Urdu People and Punjabis are the ruling elite. No need to be allergic to Urdu People only.

Tribal backwardness is related to both, the tribals and the ruling elite.

Tribals must want to change, and ruling elite should be willing to perform necessary surgeries.

Re: ex-Air Chief criticizes GOP Baloch policy

Like the PPP and Benazir Bhutto.