bro AllahkaBanda
If you can put the specific post for review into a pm for me I will take a look at it. InshaAllah I expect better from everyone. There is no favouritism here. Rather I am looking to see who is starting a combat and taking that out.
As for the topic I want to be clear about it. In the opening thread there is extensive criticism about certain goings on, which I am not clear what they are talking about.
Is it bid’a to gather in circles?
Is it bid’a to count on stones?
Is it bid’a to do tasbeeh on stones?
Is it bid’a to do tasbeeh in congregation?
Is it bid’a to do loud tasbeeh in congregation?
Is it bid’a to do all this in the masjid?
Is it not bid’a if some of these conditions are not present? Which ones? How do we know?
Furthermore is it being told that we should count our sins?
Or is this sarcasm?
And lastly how does it tie in with the idea of bid’a according to your definition?
You see why this confuses me? We need to define bid’a and apply that definition across the board otherwise we should open the doors to difference of opinion.