Let me ask you a simple hypothetical question:
**Is it possible for someone to criticize Punjab without making you think that he is hating Punjab?
**
If not, than this means that whoever criticizes, either to make it better or not, is in your opinion hating Punjab, which is obviously wrong.
If Yes, than criticism isn’t enough to conclude you that he hates Punjab..
So you see, Mr half Vulcan that in both cases you are wrong..