first of all… the context doesnt make sense…
when u use “dil ki gehrai say” u dont use it with an action instead it is used to express ur feelings… 
Main dil ki gehrai say ap ko yaad/nafraat/pyar karti hon
it doesnt make sense if you say: Main dil ki gehrai say ap ko slap/kick/punch keya
no the heart doesnt know wat u r talking abt cuz u dont make sense 