English Medium will make coming generations illiterate

Re: English Medium will make coming generations illiterate

so much burden due to involvement of two languages. been there experienced that - 4 languages

Re: English Medium will make coming generations illiterate

Well , who decides what to term as a burden and what not ?
Even with a single language...how can you tell the content , pressure , assignments , exams etc are a burden or not ?
Or did you use the term 'burden' as a comparative term here ?

Re: English Medium will make coming generations illiterate

Number of subjects (one language being used as medium of instruction and 3 languages are taught as subject) is burden for students

Re: English Medium will make coming generations illiterate

most english medium students in india have to learn three languages - english, native language, hindi. it isnt hard, but one has to think what else the student could have studied if one language was swapped out.

as for english medium etc.. isn't urdu a foreign language too? at least english opens the doors to a vaster knowledge base.

Re: English Medium will make coming generations illiterate

Urdu isn’t foreign anymore. People do understand it more than English, Arabic or Persian. The objection is raised because of skilled teachers who can teach a foreign language properly.

Is education in English-medium beneficial? | Pakistan Today | Latest news | Breaking news | Pakistan News | World news | Business | Sport and Multimedia

They made attempts to translate scientific material from Greek to Arabic and then from Arabic to English. There is always a chance to improve your language.

Re: English Medium will make coming generations illiterate

I had english..
Hindi as the second language
Arabic as the third language
I wanted to learn French too , but my parents thought it would be a burden and didn't let me.
None of the languages were a burden to me.

Re: English Medium will make coming generations illiterate

The saudis I mentioned had 2 languages as medium of instruction.
A complete set of subjects taught in English and a complete set of subjects taught in Arabic.

A child is like clay and is moulded in whtever form suits others.
Some have regular 5-7 subjects in one language , some have a combination of languages taught to their kids , some go for school subjects along with religious learning (such as hifz) ...
The options are limitless.what will you classify as a burden and what not ?
We want computers in the form of humans.

Re: English Medium will make coming generations illiterate

Extra languages become burden, when you don't got good teachers. Whats your opinion about article in post 25 (especially bold parts)?

Re: English Medium will make coming generations illiterate

I disagree. English education is very important only because it is so widely used all over the world. In places like Japan and Russia, one can study everything including sciences till the PhD level in the native language. That option is not available in our part of the world. So better to study English. That does not however mean that the native language has to be neglected.