Egg Donation is it allowed in Islam?

[diwana]

@X2

there was enough information out there and has been out there that scholars of other faiths had time to digest it ask questions and make their recommendations

our bhai sahabs did not bother..

at the end of the day, it was their responsibility to seek the knowledge, no matter how hard, and they did not, eventually they did, right, so it was delayed reaction rather than being proactive.

and there was more to it than timing issues, there were loud, very strong opinions from other ulema against it, without doing research. That is an issue, to be conservative and careful is one thing, but to come out and blast something without knowing jack is idiotic. Thankfully saner heads prevailed in the end.

Sure they did. That is good and is getting ‘better’ day by day.

Even the most intelligent and most modern people of highest knowledge from highest of current day schools, universities and institutions from modern world made blunders after blunder. Didn’t they?

Or Should we believe that these people never made wrong assumptions and were always correct in their assertion and conclusions?

Anyone who has half the knowledge of science will agree that scientific or modern day scholars have made too many serious errors and have caused people to suffer…not necessarily unknowingly.

So why we must criticize people who had no good means to get the knowledge?