Duke University's decision to sound Muslim call to prayer(azan every friday)

[P_G]

Re: Duke University’s decision to sound Muslim call to prayer(azan every friday)

@muqawwee123

P_G I can understand your sentiments and every Muslim here will understand the same.But, don’t you think that your example is not suitable for current discussion? **Your example relates to Prophet’s era and there a movement to spread Islam was taking place. When they were weak and expecting atrocities from likes of Abu Jahal, they did it secretly and when they became stronger when people like Hazrat Umar (RA) accepted Islam, they started doing it openly. Here the purpose of Muslim students in university is not preaching the religion.
**
I agree that as they have allowed others to pray, Muslim should also be allowed to do so (and someone mentioned that there are prayers rooms for Muslims in such institutions across USA). Though there are some comments in this thread, which I didn’t like myself, but if someone express fear of security based on their experience or perception, we should not attack them with the terms like ‘apologetic’, etc.

Apart from all these things, I’m still waiting for an answer to a valid point raised by TLK about whether Juma can be performed at a place without Pesh Imam and not having daily prayers arrangement (ba -jamat) 5 times a day.

1>>example bilkul darust or replies per muntabiq hay …
hazrat ummer razi Allah u tala anhu jub islam laye to un ka number 50th tha ( if its wrong plz make me correct)yane sirf 50 musalman thay or kaafir ki tadaad kitnee thee? miasjid ul haraam per kis ka qabza tha…? taqat main kon tha ?

lakin hazrat ummer razi Allahu tala anhu nay apnee shujaat ka muzahira kia ..or kufaar k aytraazat or threats ki bilkul perwah nahi ki ..or Allah nay is ammal ko qubool kia ..

yaha baat sirf yeh hay dar ul herb ki university jahan nonmuslims ki kasrat hay wahan muslman students kion Azan dainay chahtay hain ..k nonmuslims is ko pasand nahi karain gay ya un ko is ka kia faida..woh khamoshe say apnee jamaat kerwa lain …

2>>dosra tableegh-e-islam ik understood thing hai… islam k woh saray Amaal jo Aylaania hani us main tableegh khud ba khud hotee hay is ko mention kernay ki zaroorat hee nahi …

3>>security reasons per mainy koi discussion nahi rakha …jo students yeh koshish ker rahay hain un ka iman or tawakul agar mazboot hay to hum jaysay door baithay loogon k waswasay un k iman k muqablay main bohat chotay hain

4>>jumma ki namaz kis masjid main ada hotee hay yeh baat taqreeban sub muslman samjhtay hain main nahi samjhtee k us uni k Muslims nay is baray main soocha nahi ho ga…

waysay jo is k against thay woh log yeh khabar perh ker khush ho jaaain

**Duke reverses decision to allow Muslim call to prayer

**Duke reverses decision to allow Muslim call to prayer - CNN.com