Re: DR ZAKIR NAIK AT DUBAI AIRPORT EXPO ON 27 & 28th AUGUST
I think Shias are over reacting. You shia guys are allowed to curse all the Sahaba(ra) that majority of muslim respect but when it comes to someone saying mercy be upon Yazid you wage a war against him. Is that fair?
This is a misguiding statement;
the word ALL is not correct here.
neither shia curse ALL sahaba(AS) nor Sunnies do respect ALL sahaba.
Shia curse curse only those who deviated from the right path in their point of view.
and Sunni dont respect only those who were deviated from the right path in their point of view.
Shia and Sunni do have one thing in common; both of them do care for The Right Path. however both of them interpreter it differently.
i agree and i have seen many of shia book and the wording they used for sahaba is so disgusting.
i think histrory of karabala is question mark for the historian. our historain has not documented the whole incident like most shia presents . Even i have noticed contradiction of Allam Talib Johri in his majlis that is telecasted on PTV.
Now instead of just giving reference from Sunni books they are printing the real image from the those books with the title page so ppl can see. They make the offer that they can show these book on demand.
This act of Shias tell us a thing that whatever wording they are using in their books is actually showing the mirror from Sunni books. isnt it? many of the Sunni scholars said that they should fix the problem books, in other words "tahreef". which is another non-sense act.
further in my personal opinion shia ppl give too much importance to karabala event by presenting it a unique event. there are hundred of incidents in the history where muslims sacrificed their life for Islam. This is not the only event in the history of islam of this nature. what about the Hazrat Hamza shahadat who prophet called Syeddu Suhada. and what abdullah bin Zubair who fought wid yazid focre and got shaheed.
alleast you agreed that somebody else fought aginst yazied and got the status of Shahadat. Shahdat of ibine Zubair was not the only incident, you are forgetting the sadest event of Hurra. I would advise you to back to the history books and read about Hurra. how many Sahabas were killed and how many of their daughter were rapped and got pregnant in that course.
Why karbala and the Ashura is important, there are certain reasons. some of them are ask follows.
Imam Hussain is among those "Members of the Prophet's household" whom Allah has promised a complete purification...
Allah only desires to keep away the uncleanness from you, O people of the (Prophet's) House! and to purify you, a (thorough) purifying. (Quran, 33:33)
Imam Hussain is among those blessed members of the Prophet's household, whom all the Muslims have been ordered to love, to an extent that love for them has been equated with the "reward" of Prophet Muhammad's services to us....
"Say (O Muhammad!): I do not ask of you any reward (or fee) for it (my service to you) but love for my near relatives" (Quran, 42:23)
Cause of important but the most important is WHO is fighting for that cause.
why we dont see the mourning for him coz he was son of Hazrat Asma Binte Abu Bakar.
i mean this attitude is questionable ?
When Shia mourn for Sayyed usShoohada. the mourn for every shaheed. however look at the cause first. It should not be Fitna, it should not be for one's own interest.