Doubt over Nasa boy exam triumph

The Indian prime minister has cancelled a meeting with a village boy who was reported to have won an international examination organised by Nasa.
It had been widely reported that 17-year-old Saurabh Singh had beaten 200,000 students in the examination.

The reports said President APJ Kalam had passed the same test.

However, Mr Kalam’s office has denied that he had ever taken the exam. Nasa officials say they are unaware of any such exam.

The news of the boy’s examination success had been reported widely in the Indian media and on the BBC News website.

No comments to press

Doubts about the authenticity of the International Scientist Discovery examination appeared on the Indian website Rediff.com on Wednesday, shortly before Saurabh Singh was due to meet President Kalam in Delhi and be congratulated on his achievement.

Later on Wednesday, Nasa spokeswoman Debbie Rahn, who has worked for the agency for more than 30 years, told the BBC News website: “I have been unable to confirm that such an exam exists. I have checked all the appropriate offices in Nasa.”

The president’s spokesman, SM Khan, told the BBC that, contrary to widespread reports, President Kalam had never sat for such an examination.

Journalists were eagerly waiting to talk to the boy and his father after their 10-minute meeting with the president.

But Saurabh and his father refused to talk to the press and left in a car.

The two were also supposed to meet Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh later on Wednesday.

But the prime minister’s press adviser Sanjaya Baru said that the meeting has been cancelled after the president’s statement.

Saurabh Singh comes from the district of Ballia, a poor area of the northern state of Uttar Pradesh.

The Uttar Pradesh chief secretary VK Mittal told the BBC that the Ballia administrator had been asked to collect “all papers and certificates” of the “examination” from Sourabh.

“There is reasonable doubt about Sourabh’s performance now,” Mr Mittal said.

A teacher at Saurabh’s school Hema Chandra in Ballia said that a local newspaper had first reported Saurabh’s exam success.

“We contacted Saurabh immediately. He confirmed he had topped the examination.”


this is a killer, how indian media create so much noise on even a un existant exam by NASA
just wondering how daring he is even to meet president and PM and never disclosed this lie before. he should have won the award for that atleast.

this is another example just how media can create publicity bubble without looking in to facts, how many other issue could have been reported this way without facts. :slight_smile:

Re: Doubt over Nasa boy exam triumph

I aint allowing any racial or nationalist slurs in my forum - in humour or otherwise!
(Post edited!)

Re: Doubt over Nasa boy exam triumph

lol, remember when zeeTV created so much noise about a news claiming that indian "hackers" have hacked pak govt's web site ?

it turned out that some lame indians had bought a domain by the name of pakgov.com.pk and were claiming that this was the official pak govt's web site and that they have hacked it lol!!

www.pak.gov.pk is the official pak web site though

Re: Nasa boy exam triumph was a fraud

fun part is bbc too reported this news and had their foot-in-the-mouth next day :smack:

Re: Doubt over Nasa boy exam triumph

nasa is proly north american sindhi association

Re: Doubt over Nasa boy exam triumph

I don’t think that’s accurate - I remember some Pakistan official actually releasing a statement warning against RAW when the hacking occurred.

Re: Doubt over Nasa boy exam triumph

haha.

Re: Doubt over Nasa boy exam triumph

Lol...

Re: Doubt over Nasa boy exam triumph

Sorry Double Post! Duh!

Re: Doubt over Nasa boy exam triumph

Actually Pakistani sites do get hacked by Indians, just like the guys at Pakcert, Phoneynets and spookeypancakes attack and Indian websites.

But what i hate most are laim script kids, people that just use previously published codes on the net to crack websites and deface them (Not cool at all).