Do you Agree with this shair?

Parveen Shakir said:

**Wo kahin bhi gaya lota tau mere paas aya
Bus yehi ik baat **hai **** achi mere harjai ki

Do you agree to forgive such harjai each and every time? Will you forgive someone for disloyalty? Is there any limit to Bardasht & Sacrifice in love?

re: Do you Agree with this shair?

shaa'irii kii sunyaa alag hii huaa kartii hai jahaN shaa'ir/shaa'ira apne aapko mazloom tasavvur kartaa/kartii hai aur maHboob ke haathoN kiye gaye mazaalim aur jaur o jafaa ko baa'is-e-sad hazaar faKhr o iftiKhaar gardaante/gardaantii haiN. They celebrate their miseries! :) is nukta e nazar se to shaa'ira kaa mauqif qaabil-e-daad o taHseen hai magar fil-Haqeeqat aise mazaalim ko sahnaa ba-zaat-e-Khud ek zulm hai.

re: Do you Agree with this shair?

So you mean forgiving 'Harjai' makes him more 'Harjai'. Jaise shair ne kaha tha:

Kar Kar ke minnaten teri aadaten bighad din
Humne apne hathon tumhe sangdil bana diya

But we all know 'Insaan khata ka putla hai' aur wo insaan jisse aap mehboob kehte / samjhate ho, kia aap ussay chance nahin do ge?

Re: Do you Agree with this shair?

I concur to whatever you are saying ...I think if you are in ISHQ with someone ..you just don't see what the other person is doing or did to you all you feel is love..LOVE actually never dies :D

Re: Do you Agree with this shair?

:k: This reminds me Ashfaq Ahmed who said ‘Mehboob woh hota hai jis ka Na theek bhi theek lage’. Further, we listen to this line ‘Love is Blind’ on regular basis.. but do ppl are able to forgive all the times. I mean to say, one can forgive a mistake one-two times, but whether a Habitual Harjai deserve this treatment or not?

Re: Do you Agree with this shair?

It depends on Harjai :wub: BTW only a person who have fallen in Ishaq can say this and this is beyond of ordinary persons :cobra:

Re: Do you Agree with this shair?

I assume it has nothing to do with "lotas" discussed in PA? :D

Re: Do you Agree with this shair?

I've seen examples of 'Herjai' bin forgiven time and again so I think perpetuity in forgiveness exists. Actually you just can't help yourself in situation where you become slave of your heart.

Re: Do you Agree with this shair?

Kia PA forums wale Lotay kabhi wapis bhi aate hain? :hmmm:

Re: Do you Agree with this shair?

Yehi log hain jo bar bar dhoka khate hain aur phir kehte hain:

Bewafaon se wafa karke guzaari hai hayat
main barsta raha veeranon pe badal ki tarah

Re: Do you Agree with this shair?

Depends on what? Type of Harjai or type of relationship with Harjai?

Re: Do you Agree with this shair?

Per yeh laa'ilaaj loag hain ..becharay :D

Re: Do you Agree with this shair?

Koi Humse Bhe Puch Lay :(

Re: Do you Agree with this shair?

Kahiye Janab.. Hum hama tan gosh hain.

Re: Do you Agree with this shair?

^ Ishq kay hathon tabah :p

Re: Do you Agree with this shair?

Becharay kiyun? La'ilaaj sahi hai kiyunke apne kiye ka ilaaj shayad Hakeem Luqman ke paas bhi na tha.

Re: Do you Agree with this shair?

Nhe rehnay day ap :(

Tabah o barbaad :p

Re: Do you Agree with this shair?

Tu nay dil mera toda, kahin ka na chhora, Sanam Bewafa. :(

Aap ne us harjai ko maaf kia ya nahin?

Re: Do you Agree with this shair?

Jera Zakhm Dilbar Yaar Daway
Zakhm Seh Laye Kurr Layi Da Nahi

Re: Do you Agree with this shair?

Piyar undhaa hota hai. Uss koh pa lenay kee khawhish mein sub bardashat ker lety hain log.