Lol, yes, it can happen. If you think about it, a person’s talents/accomplishments reflect character traits about them. It doesn’t provide a comprehensive understanding of who they are, but it does give you some insight. Playing the piano well involves traits like persistence and a certain type of sensitivity.
Yeah I’ve seen people become more attracted to someone if they find out they have a talent or even any other thing about their background that’s a pleasant surprise. Like this one girl wasn’t really into me but later told me she liked me when she find out she and my mom were the same ethnicity lol and she was surprised.
Yup, happened twice. Once same thing as yours, I found myself being attracted to a friend when I saw him playing piano, he could play amr diab’s “Tamally Maak” really well. Another time, I found out the guy could play guitar and had a lovely singing voice.
A good sense of humor immensely attracts me. A person can go from 5 to 9 in minutes if she can make me laugh.
And has happened the other way round as well, some who acted very uptight suddenly started to try to please as they knew me a bit more but didn’t ask what it was.