The prophet (pbuh) was human, but he is the perfection that we should all try to emulate.
This is because of the way he lead his life and nothing to do with whether he had a shadow or not. What difference does it make anyway? Study the Quran and look at the verses in which the non beleivers are asking for some miracles from our prophet(pbuh) to prove that he was the messenger of Allah. If he did'nt have a shadow then that would be an example would it not? BUT the Quran is cited as the ONLY miracle that is required for anyone to beleive in Allah and his prophet (Pbuh). Its quite obvious that this is not enough for the people today.
All I can say for certain is that the prophet would not have sinned, whether he erred or misjudged things as a human is another matter. Why does'nt anyone look at the Quranic verses presented in this post so far (Achtungs post for e.g)?
(34:50)"Say: If I err, I err only to my own loss, and if I am rightly guided it is because of that which my Lord hath revealed unto me. Lo! He is Hearer, Nigh."
"Allah pardon you! Why did you give them leave until those who spoke the truth had become manifest to you and you had known the liars?" [9:43]
If Allah inspires us to do something he surely would not inspire to err in anyway would he? Or would he inspire a certain action and then pardon us for following his inspiration?
Lets not get personal guys and stick to the discussion without name calling.
Show me a hadith or qurani aya where it is said that phrophet did not had SHADOW, its just ignorence and matter of respect you people thing saying that MOhammad did not had shadow will increase the respect that you present for him, show me something from hadith or quran!
Ppl trying to prove that Mohammad(pbuh) made mistakes(Naouzubillah) can plez explain me that if He made mistakes then why are we following (Naouzubillah) a mistaken person??????
Qur'an 21:107
And We did not send you (O Muhammad) except as a Mercy to the worlds.
I am Lost!
I never knew that islam has became that much Mod. that ppl have started denying the fact that Prophet(pbuh) is a Model Of Perfection for the whole world, away from sins and flaws, a model to be followed.
Secondly someone gives here some verses of Quran about Some prophets asking for forgiveness by Allah, can you plez give me A SINGLE VERSE about Prophet(pbuh) making his apology for any of His mistake???????
Plus Zara are you visiting some "Ahmedi" web-sites??????
I think enough has been said about this issue. If you want to continue this discussion in a normal and rational manner I suggest that you start another thread as this one is getting too long and is begining to deviate from the intial thots expressed by people.
Thank you.
ConsertiveGirl you are very much rihgt...Zara has been visiting those sites where she found those hadith or qurani verses...i asked her many time to give me the addresss for that site but she ignores i dont she wants us to know....anyways may allah guied all of us to right path and...forgive us from our past sinss....
Please refrain from name calling and insulting other people.
Thank you
And you claim to follow Quran and Hadith! You idiot..do you know who SAyyedna Ibn Abbas radhi Allah anhu was?? He was one of the greatest SAHABI of The Holy Prophet sal Allahu alayhi wa sallam! And he has narrated many many hadith...but your fcomments sohw that you are not interested in truth only your narrow interpretations!
And there ARE hadith which state that Habib Allah had no shadow sal Allahu alayhi wa sallam..but you're not gonna believe them nayway so what's the point.....
[This message has been edited by hmcq (edited October 05, 1999).]
Asif bahiiiii you calling me something does NOT make me one because i will never be what you are!!!!! i know you angry because you cant provide truth you cant defend what your saying..you might COME UP with something which you might call truth but there is NO hadith or qurani verse that say that mohammad did not had shadow. i dont think you know how to read or maybe you dont have any truth to show me...NOW stupid i asked show me some hadiths or verses from quran that say that MOhammad did not had shadow....HELLOO write the hadith here tell me where you find it....i dont care who narrates hadith as long as they are from books of hadiths...dont give me shit like this person narrates this hadith show me the hadith. Besides it is stupid to say that mohammad that we call a HUMAN did not had shadow have some common sense please!!! How can a living thing like human not have shadow???????? You people are soo ignorent you THINK saying that mohammad did not had shadow increases the respect that you have for mohammad that is stupid!!!! we should not say things that does not exist in islam, we should not creat new things in islam on which we think that they are right but they have no base or existence in ISLAM. Please avoid creating innovations in islam.
Salam everyone!!!
Brothers & sisters it is much easier to pick on our deen(religion)than pick on our selves. There happens to be a reason for that because we muslims have become so affraid of consequences because as soon some one say or write against our religion,first of all we look on each other whether it is a by a Bangali poet,Pakistani rushdee or someone else,second we look on west that what statement should we use which should not upset western,s and our aid from them.we try to please west more than we try to please Allah SWT,and that is why we are doomed in this world and who knows about after worlds ????????
In fact we have created liberal Islam among us muslims. I agree with most of you that little knowledge is dangrous !!!!!!!!!!
OK I am now closing this thread as it has gotten rather long and is now becoming too acrimonious. If anyone feels like continuing this topic, please feel free to start another thread.
Thank you