Details of interpreting verses from the Qur'an and obvious blunders

[kchughtai]

Re: Details of interpreting verses from the Qur’an and obvious blunders

@psyah

Peace kchughtai

Imam Malik (R) believed Isa (AS) has died? I have not heard of such a thing … may be you are right … (the fact is we follow the majority opinion, but for academic reasons I need more than this) … I checked up where you got this from …

I found a reference in your articles referring to a book written by a Shi’a scholar

***Majma Biharul Anwar (1694 AD) - by Mulla Muhammad Baqir

---

Now I need to check this book to see where and how this scholar gets the idea you are portraying - given that your article has correctly cited this too.

Can anyone give me a link to a copy of this book?

This link says that Imam Malik wrote this book !!!

Claims of the Promised Messiah

Before you laugh, let me tell you this is not my source and it is actually the first time I got to know this site and when I visited this site, here is what is written over there

Hadhrat Imam Malik - ***The writer of the book ‘Majmaul Bihar’ said although many people say that Hadhrat Isa did not die, Hadhrat Imam Malik used to say that Hadhrat Isa has passed away. (Majmaul Bihar, Vol 1, P286)

---

Tell me where does it say that it was written by Imam Malik. It is pretty evident from the above statement that someone else wrote this book. I think you are in too much hurry to reply.

Also Bihar-ul-Anwar is not the only reference in this regard. I will get back to you on this soon