Details of interpreting verses from the Qur'an and obvious blunders

[psyah]

Re: Details of interpreting verses from the Qur’an and obvious blunders

@Mr.Popat

You must see the whole verse in its entirety. I am not just commenting on the part where it says that they used to eat. What i’m trying to draw your attention to is that in the verse, Jesus a.s is combined by Allah with the prophets who passed away before Him. It says that Isa a.s was a messenger just like them. Messengers before him have passed away. Now, since Isa a.s was also a messenger like others before him, and since they died, so did Isa a.s. That is why Allah says that He along with his mother used to eat food. Its not about them still eating. Had they still been eating, then Allah needed to say that messengers like him have passed away. There was no need for this statement. This is clear enough that once someone dies, they stop eating. Allah is NOT only denying Jesus a.s as God by saying he used to eat food, but also giving argument that He died like other prophets, and that he used to eat food. On the contrary, Allah never dies , and he does not need food. He is paak from all this.

You are coming up with your own explanation about how He a.s is still eating and is still alive. The whole purpose of this verse is to tell the christians that he died. Your reasoning is very weak !

Peace Mr.Popat

I’ve already spoken to you about the translation of the term “Qad Khalat” - it means “have come and gone” - it can include those who are still alive and those who have died …

You have a fixation over food … and death

I have shown that the Arabic of the term - “Kaana Ya’kulaani” is not perfect - which means it does not include that idea that those who ate are not eating now.

I have also shown that Qad Khalat does not necessarily mean death

I have tried to show that eating is enough for a person not to be called Divine

And it is clear that no where in the Qur’an does it specifically say Isa (AS) has died, and where it could have been used - the example of food was used instead…

Historically we have no body of Isa (AS) … [But modern claims from your community say otherwise]

Christian reports say he (AS) Ascended physically and our Qur’an say that he (AS) was “taken up”
And our hadith say he will “descend”