Do not expect the whole world to agree to your POV or see things with the same goggles as yours.
Some people will question and others will not it is the responsibility of the person telling the story to make it appealing to majority , not every story can be guaranteed to be appealing to the whole world.
^ we all are ready to learn life’s lessons from GEO ke draamay, Razia Butt ke novels and Shoaib Mansoor kee movie, so why cant we learn something good from this story, even if its fake or has loop holes.
Again you cannot expect everybody to learn lesson from any one or all of the stories , some will question and they have the right to do so.
Why do we have so many tafasir ul Quran ? Because people had questions and someone felt the need to answer those questions.
I have nothing against anecdotes but the rules for made up stories that have a moral lesson is:
a) Be honest - it’s only a story - don’t start off saying “this is absolutely true”
b) Ask people to share as they will, but don’t ask or subdue them to continuing an email chain or something bad will happen or something good will not happen.
c) Don’t compromise the plot - the girl who meets her death upon sujud is amazing for only those people who are already inclined towards a secure understanding and belief of the aakhira … this story could backfire and people could think religious people die young.
d) Make it realistic - If the mother had died instead of the bride that would have been more easily believed.
I am not saying anyone over here to see things from my side nor i want anyone to agree with me. Its about getting something positive out of such stories & if not than don’t reply, what good will anyone get of doing nitpicking thats what i don’t understand.
& I don;t think this story will have any negative impact on anyone’s life ,if someone try really hard to find out one then its another thing
Fake or True, Logical or not, the idea of the story is correct. Pray before you are prayed upon.
All this negativism in this discussion is nothing short of our own sad state of affairs in life. This very life where the focus is all upon this world, which itself is not going to last for us more than 60/70/80/90 or 100 odd years at the most.
Will we be able to defy Allah with all our clever logic through which we can shut the mouth of others around us?
I am scared for all those who are ridiculing the OP Poster..
Take the good things out of it and forget the bad… and I honestly in my eyes see no bad, all it is one Muslim telling others to get close to ALLAH when you still have a chance..