Dark side of Muslim World -Taslima Nasreen

:sunny:I dont know if Taslima Nasreen is product of DYSFUNCTIONAL FAMILY or typical Muslim family so as to CLAIM TO KNOW ABOUT GROWING AS FEMALE IN A MUSLIM WORLD

Is Bangladesh responsible for bad experience of ONE dysfunctional family or she ios wrong to claim that she is product of Muslinm Family & not screwd up perverted Dysfunctional family so common here in the west Incest, pedophillia ,homosexuality ,lesbianism rapes single mother & more than 50% out of wed lock pregnancy & child birth :eeh: :eeh:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A411-2002Sep11.html

Blossoming in the Shadows
‘Meyebela: My Bengali Girlhood: A Memoir of Growing Up Female in a Muslim World’ by Taslima Nasrin

	Sunday's Book World, as well as daily reviews, news and features, can be found on our Books page. The Washington Post Book Club gives you access to discounts, discussions, special events and more. 

		
		


			
	E-Mail This Article
	
	Printer-Friendly Version 
	
	Subscribe to The Post 

By Nora Boustany,
a diplomatic correspondent for The Post, who has covered the Middle East and Islam extensively as a foreign correspondent
Wednesday, September 11, 2002; Page C04

MEYEBELA
My Bengali Girlhood: A Memoir of Growing Up Female in a Muslim World
By Taslima Nasrin
Translated from the Bengali by Gopa Majumdar
Steerforth. 308 pp. $26

Taslima Nasrin, the fiery feminist from Bangladesh who angered the Muslim clergy in her country by questioning the Koran and writing about sexuality, has written a brutally honest and brave memoir of her childhood to the age of 14. In “Meyebela,” Nasrin depicts with horror the inequality between men and women; the verbal, emotional and physical abuse heaped on female relatives; and the exploitation and humiliation of lower-caste servants.

By the age of 7, she tells us, she had been sexually molested by a maternal uncle and repeatedly raped one afternoon after a paternal uncle lured her to his bedside with magic tricks. Nasrin was a spirited little girl in shorts who played hopscotch and yearned to follow her older brothers and their friends to the river or climb onto the roof of the house to engage in war games and watch passersby. She was constantly pushed back into the shadows. Her mind was irrepressible, however – especially as she sought to come to terms with the hypocrisy around her, masked by religion and tradition.

“Ma,” Nasrin’s affectionate yet seemingly clueless mother, unattractive with her dull brown eyes, hollow cheeks and puffy nose, was an embittered woman, driven to blind faith and mindless rituals. She became the devout follower of a religious figure, Amirullah, to soothe her wounded ego after Nasrin’s father, Baba, entered into a liaison with a beautiful mistress and flirted with Ma’s prettier sisters. Ma used her expert knowledge of Islam to upstage Baba in front of the children, thus reclaiming some of the power she had lost to him.

Ma’s domestic struggles help to flesh out, in the smaller compass of family life, the appeal of Islamic authority in much larger settings and struggles over power – a dynamic that still eludes many commentators in the wake of the terrorist attacks that occurred a year ago today. As a religion of empowerment, Islam can place a believer facing seemingly insurmountable odds on an equal footing with an adversary – or any target symbolizing that enemy’s strength. In the end, Ma has an affair with Baba’s brother, but her retreat into an often unreasonable and always passionate piety affords the most constant remedy for her pain.

Baba, better educated than his wife, moved up in the world and became the family tyrant. A doctor and pharmacist, he caned his children to make sure they studied hard. He sat next to little Taslima at her desk at night as she grappled with English grammar, primed to strike her whenever she yawned or made a mistake. He doted on her when she performed well – especially after one brother ran away with a Hindu girl and the other dropped out of medical school to earn a psychology degree. But owing to his brutal methods, his daughter grew to despise him – and his constant urging that she make something of herself amid the poverty and uncertainties of postcolonial Bangladesh. “All I had seen so far in my life was his arrogance; all I had heard were his roars,” she writes.

Torn between her mother’s unquestioning faith and her father’s rigid dictates, the precocious girl set about unraveling some of her mother’s mystifying and dubious assumptions. According to Ma, saying a prayer, then standing at the door of each room of the house and blowing was supposed to drive away all trouble. But when a storm broke without warning, neither Ma’s wailing and pleading to Allah nor her conservative Islamic garb, simulating that of the prophet’s wives, was of any use in stopping the raging winds and rains. That incident, and many other of Ma’s unverifiable beliefs, such as “the moon has its own light” and “the earth always stands still,” brought the girl to the fundamental question fueling her rebellious childhood: “Which was true? Science or the Koran? . . . As far as I knew, the earth did not stand still. It moved around the sun.”

Nasrin’s memoir offers a rare look at a little-known country cramped by poverty as it struggled to come of age. She sheds light on this large subject through an engaging string of anecdotes about her relatives, as well as discussions of how many traditional cultural and culinary habits survived the war that split Bangladesh from Pakistan. “I had never seen so much grief in our neighborhood. It was as if the entire neighborhood had decided not to eat, or laugh, or play or sleep,” she writes of one especially grim period. Later, she observes: “It did not take us long to get back to normal. Human nature is like that – people cannot carry the weight of grief for very long.”

The theme of injustice toward women in Islam has become routine, but here it gains fresh currency, thanks to the fervor with which the author looks, through the inquisitive eyes of her younger self, for the truth behind seemingly innocent family incidents. Her condemnations can sound repetitive and sophomoric, but they come from within a Muslim society emerging from the puzzling contradictions of postcolonial South Asia.

Ultimately, Baba’s beatings and bribes failed with Nasrin, although she did fulfill his expectations by becoming a doctor; today, living in exile, she is a novelist and poet. Doubtless some of the confidence she has shown later in life was forged in the adversity of her childhood; even as she took blows on her back she steeled herself for life as a free agent. “I, in my corner, I continued to grow,” she writes.

This moving memoir attempts to demonstrate how it is possible for young women to reach within themselves and nurture their own spiritual life in spite of the physical and emotional pain that men – and tradition-bound societies – can inflict upon them.

© 2002 The Washington Post Company

Gymnasophyst performing gymnastics with the English language again.

Anyway, that’s one screwed up family. Not a very flattering portrayal of her mother either, I can’t think of many people who would write about their mum like that.

This has already been posted here:

http://www.gupistan.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=71740

Where does Islam say that the earth stands still?

I think she doesn't know too much about the Islamic faith...but nonetheless, you can't ignore that all of this stuff DOES happen in south asia, despite the presence of Islam.

the lady needs to differentiate what is of islam from what is of the society she lives in.... :( but i do hope she enjoyed her few minutes in the sun...she had to stoop so much to get them...

Xtreme Bhai
I

Taslima herself is hard on her family .

About my two posts :slight_smile:

When i cant be sure if my post on Pak or World will escape the WRATH of M…N :rolleyes:
I HAD THIS AS back up post for i know M…N is tnot the moderator on CRNR …or IS HE ? :eek:

With anonimity of nicks .i sometime think all moderators are one with diff, nick Xtreme ,WHAT A NIGHTMARE for me :eek:

am tongue in cheek ..i Defenitely dont think her family is screwed but if she wants to villify her own family IT DOESN OT SPEAK HIGH FOR HER :rolleyes:
Such is luck

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by isloo_ki_anarkali: *
the lady needs to differentiate what is of islam from what is of the society she lives in.... :( but i do hope she enjoyed her few minutes in the sun...she had to stoop so much to get them...
[/QUOTE]

That's exactly what i was thinking.

>>Nasrin was a spirited little girl in shorts who played hopscotch and yearned to follow her older brothers and their friends to the river or climb onto the roof of the house to engage in war games and watch passersby. <<
This sounds a lot like my Nani when she was very young - Islam never "repressed" her and forced her to sit by the sidelines. >>The theme of injustice toward women in Islam has become routine, but here it gains fresh currency, thanks to the fervor with which the author looks...<< Replace "Islam" with "Muslim countries" and the sentence sounds accurate and infinitely better. The lady would do better to use Islam as a springboard for advocating womens' rights in South Asia, rather than heaping her anger towards the Quran.

Personally i never had much respect for her as an intellectual ,writer,doctor …

No doubt without Indian (w,Bengal) political support of demeaning muslim islam & bangladesh Nasrins novel or articles would never have found publisher agent publicists p.r. & FANS

All her work is written in CRUDE bengali ,sort of uneducated bengali colloqualism.ALL her books are read after translation by the same lady Muzumdar who herself is an accomplished english writer .How much she translates or INSERTS or ADDS is known to Nasreen alone .

Its not difficult for Dissidents like Nasreen to find sponsors & she has monetary help in Germany Sweden & u.k.

What can you think of a very moderate intelligent doctor who doesnt practice medicine but writes in crude BENGALI which miraculously sell to provide her celebrity life style :rolleyes:

As far as crtique of islam is no more than hARD LIFE SUPPOSEDLY SHE EXPERIENCED with a tyrant overbearing Angry father .What fault can a humble religous mother praying & meditating in her religion can have i fail to see.Many of us have mothers like that .As long it gives peace of mind to such mother there is nothing wrong in it in my opinion.:k:

quite interesting

itn not the dark side of Islam, but the dark side of her own family....
Islam or the Muslim World do not order nor cherish such acts....

and to be sincere, i think she is just making all this up, to get attention....
u know the psychological effect of PITY....

perverted is one word to describe all this BULLS**T

Guys, its her memoir, its only her who has lived that (her very own) life. What exactly can we say about her life? Why are all of you assuming that what she is saying is wrong? You may not like it but thats what she has been through and she has every right to express it in any way she wants to. Not all of us have to agree on everything. Everyone has a right to question things around them even if they do go against your or my faith. Her life, her choices.

Secondly, the issue of repressing women ... well, everything contributes to it and just blaming the society is not the whole story.

Scratch

Just as Taslima has been provided a Larger than life Canvas to paint her Expression by Anti Muslim media &countries & organization,

ppl. here get only small audience express there OPINION.

Why your sympathy for more than usual. :nono:

Dont we have million dysfunctional families in USA where Father is incestuous?Where husband is abusive ?Where Father is strict disciplinarian?

Atleast he MADE her a medical doctor .Thast she chose not to be a dioctor by which she could have done more for abusive kids than by being Agent provocateuer of the anti Islam group who use her as “irritant” annoying ,Non Issue & cheap propoganda.

There is not one point in her logic or assertion that is sensible to reasoning.

WE know that she NEVER was a muslim why is she made to represent muslim woman .

She even looks like androgenous but its the women to say whether they consider her there representative or not ?

By her content of argument ,she does not have any islamic knowledge.

"The theme of injustice toward women in Islam has become routine..."

I disagree with the text mentioning inustice in Islam towards women. Indeed it is apparently clear that there is no such injustice towards any gender or race or age group in Islam. Rather, these are manifestations of Muslim behaviour, but I wouldn't blame the author for thinking this was so - to those who think otherwise, I can only advise you to do some further research.

Mushi :confused:

Explain your answer

“wouldn’t blame the author for thinking this was so - to those who think otherwise, I can only advise you to do some furtherresearch” :confused: :rolleyes:

If the person was some illiterate woman from Bhawalpur ,yes BUT after mbbs degree from Bangladesh Nothing is excused…you r now fair game man or woman ..all the gloves are off if the attack is ON ME .AS A MUSLIM :smash:

I have sisters ,& to think i was unfair or my parent were misogynist or even my religion was oppressive selectively only on my sister ..no sir ..there i draw the line for WE ALL HAVE SACRIFICED FOR EACH OTHER IN THE FAMILY & NO ONE ENJOYED AT THE BACK OF OTHER BOY OR GIRL
:Rocketup:

Gymnasophyst, USA might be whatever you say it is; and Tasleema Nasreen might have as little knowledge of Islam as you say she has but pray tell me why does anyone who dares to speak against either religion or the norms of our society gets branded as non-Muslim, pervert, and screwed up and all?

We do not have to assume that it is all hunky and dory in our part of the world. The very problems that you have mentioned for US, also corrupt our own societies. We just follow a hush-hush policy and if someone does show us the mirror, all of us just jump on that person. If these are the things that happened to her (and this obviously does not show a very happy childhood) and she has depicted an honest picture of that, along with her own personal feelings about why the things are the way they are, then why should it be a problem with the rest of us? What is so unbelievable about that memoir … the tyrannical Baba; her Ma’s relation with Baba’s brother; Tasleema’s sexual molestation by her uncles; or the unfair treatment her father meted out to her mother? Don’t tell me that our society is totally devoid of such behavior and elements. Ok, she is not the true representative of the Muslim women but then the Muslim world should do something to bring forward the true representative.

according to me tasleema is a opportunist woman
she wrote a novel lajja which was a third rate novel a school kid would have written a better novel
anyways i appreciate the fact that she highlighted the suffering of hindu minority in bangladesh
but its unfortunate that in a educated country like india where there was a holocast of muslims no hindu version of tasleem stood up

YOU DONT GET IT AS YET …IS IT ?/:confused:

I have lived as a muslim ,i have no qualm as calling spade spade ..Call your family Dysfunctional as Barbra Sreisand ,Tina Turner ,or any number of other ordinary ppl. in evening news every day .

Just take out the word generalising your life as MUSLIM or you even representative of a Muslimcountry ,

Just being from Islamic republic of Bangl;adesh or Pakistan make you muslim & EVERY THING YOU & YOUR FAMILY DOES BECOMES MUSLIM WAYS ???:confused:

Its like libel by calling it MUSLIM you invite involvement from me & ppl like me .:nono:

I know what it is ,it is a propoganda stunt of Hindu Bengalis fom W.Bengal & same RSS HIndutva who kil muslim in gujrat

Go watch Soul of India on PBS & read who maligns Islam ..it is Indian RSS VHP & Sanghi :devil: