Well it depends if you are criticising their unjust actions of those talibans (without criticising the religion) or the religion. The later is not acceptable.
i 2nd ur views as i consider it a moderate and balanced approch.
delimma is that few ppl start criticizing the principles of shariah without having the proper knowledge of the rationale and background of that principle. beside their knowledge is very limited about shariah on overall basis.
few others are indulge in copy pasting from the anti islamic websites instead of sharing their own thoughts.
i think if someone have ne query in mind he shud consult relegious scholars instead of start criticisng the principle here at this forum.
may show all of us right path.