Cricinfo copying and pasting from PAK sites!!!

Lately I have noticed cricinfo basically copying and pasting from esp. Dawn and Dailytimes websites. I mean literally word for word!!

I was expecting better from them. Whats worse they don’t even acknowledge the original source!!

Talk about ‘sasti’ journalism. Make of it what you will…

(cricinfo today)
Former players question team composition

Former Pakistan players have blamed the side’s unexpected loss to Sri Lanka in the Galle Test on poor team composition, with Moin Khan and Sarfraz Nawaz questioning the absence of Fawad Alam, a left-hand batsman who also bowls left-arm spin, from the XI.
“[Alam] scored 80 odd runs in the warm-up game, he’s also an excellent fielder and a player who can also bowl left-arm spin, I fail to understand why he was left out,” Moin, a former captain, told AP.
Pakistan were set 168 to win the Test and began day four needing 97 with eight wickets in hand. They proceeded to lose all eight for 46 runs in the first session.
Former fast bowler Sarfraz criticised captain Younis Khan’s decision to bring himself on in the first session of the Test and said key bowlers Abdul Razzaq and Danish Kaneria had been left out. “I was watching the [batting] collapse on television and told myself ‘maybe its just a dream, the real match will begin afterwards,’” Nawaz said. “It was unbelievable the way our batting collapsed, I was not expecting such a performance. Where was Abdul Razzaq, where was Fawad Alam, where was Danish Kaneria?”
Ijaz Ahmed, the former Pakistan batsman, said there was a psychological problem with the side’s batsmen when it came to chasing small totals and suggested a batting coach. “Both coaches [Intikhab Alam and Aaqib Javed] are bowlers so it leaves only captain Younis Khan and… vice-captain Misbah-ul-Haq to guide other batsmen,” Ijaz told Geo TV. “I think we should have a batting coach who can teach the finer points of the game to our batsmen.”

http://www.cricinfo.com/slvpak2009/content/current/story/413259.html


(Dailytimes last night)
Wrong team picked, says former Test cricketers

*By Rizwan Ali *

ISLAMABAD: Sarfraz Nawaz and Moin Khan were among a host of former Test cricketers who blamed bad team selection for Pakistan’s stunning 50-run loss to Sri Lanka on the fourth day of the first Test at Galle. “Where was Abdul Razzaq, where was Fawad Alam, where was Danish Kaneria?” asked ex-Test fast bowler Nawaz. All three of those Pakistan players watched from sidelines as the batting order succumbed to disciplined Sri Lankan bowlers for a paltry 117 in the last innings – chasing modest 168-run for victory on Tuesday. Pakistan were in sight of victory when play resumed with two days remaining, needing just 97 runs to overhaul the victory target with eight wickets in hand.

However, left-arm spinner Rangana Herath (4-15) and seamer Thilan Thushara (2-21) hurried the Pakistan collapse and the visitors lost their last eight wickets for meager 47 runs to be bowled out in the second innings.

“I was watching the (batting) collapse on television and told myself ‘maybe its just a dream, the real match will begin afterwards,”’ Nawaz said. “It was unbelievable the way our batting collapsed, I was not expecting such a performance.” Pakistan captain Younis Khan, who led his country to victory in the Twenty20 World Cup in England last month, had to come on to bowl before lunch on the first day of the test match. The move surprised Nawaz. “It shows that you haven’t done your homework and left out two of your key bowlers,” Nawaz said, referring to Kaneria and Razzaq.

Another former Test captain Moin blamed poor team composition and said left-handed batsman Alam should have been included in the XI. “Alam scored 80 odd runs in the warm-up game, he’s also an excellent fielder and a player who can also bowl left-arm spin, I fail to understand why he was left out,” Moin said. It could have been highest run-chase at Galle International Stadium in 14 Test matches as the teams have struggled batting fourth at a venue which was completely rebuilt after the Tsunami struck Sri Lanka in 2004. “There is some psychological problem with our batsmen as we have struggled to achieve small totals in Test matches for quite a long time now,” another former Test batsman Ijaz Ahmed told Geo Television.

Ahmed suggested Pakistan’s batting needed to be fine-tuned and the Pakistan Cricket Board should hire a specialist batting coach. Presently Pakistan team coaches are former Test leg-spinner Intikhab Alam and ex-Test medium fast bowler Aaqib Javed.

“Both coaches are bowlers so it leaves only captain Younis and somewhat vice-captain Misbahul Haq to guide other batsmen,” Ahmed said. “I think we should have a batting coach who can teach the finer points of the game to our batsmen.”

http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2009\07\08\story_8-7-2009_pg2_9

re: Cricinfo copying and pasting from PAK sites!!!

**:hmmm:

Recently … cricinfo is giving more importance to Pakistan Cricket then in Past
**

Re: Cricinfo copying and pasting from PAK sites!!!

good catch GA.

It cant be a policy decision by cricinfo. They might have a deal with the newspaper, or some kind of deal with the authors.

The most likely scenario is that the author Rizwan Ali got lazy and filed the same story with a new title and a little juggling to both The daily times and Cricinfo.

Re: Cricinfo copying and pasting from PAK sites!!!

I don't get it. Unless I am missing something...I did not see the "literally word for word copying" in the above example post by GA.

btw, could it be that Rizwan Ali of Daily Times copied stuff from Cricinfo instead.

Some1 please read again and look at the timings. cricinfo's account is basically a summarised version and > 90% of the words are the same and I dare say not for the first time that I have seen this. I read Rizwan's article last evening almost 24 hours before cricinfo reporting it today

Re: Cricinfo copying and pasting from PAK sites!!!

i don't see the copy paste. but that could be because i have also been reading posts by Sheen.

articles are similar but can’t really say if one is a copy of the other. The main similarities are in the quotes which could’ve been given to a third-party media outlet, and both pubs may have rights to use them.

:rotfl:

Re: Cricinfo copying and pasting from PAK sites!!!

**Another e.g.

Srcs: DAWN.COM | Cricket | I considered suing PCB: Akhtar
*(http://www.cricinfo.com/pakistan/content/current/story/413417.html)

=========DAWN

  1. On pic
    ‘I kept quiet because I have a central contract and didn’t want to offend the Pakistan Cricket Board.’ -AFP (file)

  2. Akhtar is in category A of the PCB’s centrally contracted players, who are barred from openly criticizing the cricket board’s decisions.

  3. The injury-prone fast bowler last played a test match against India in 2007 before he was sidelined for 14 months due to fitness and disciplinary problems.
    He has made two unimpressive comebacks to international cricket this year, in one-day series against Sri Lanka and Australia, but the enigmatic paceman known as the ‘Rawalpindi Express’ believes he can get back to his best.

  4. Pakistan’s former coach, the late Bob Woolmer, advised Akhtar to shorten his long run-up to prolong his cricketing career, but Akhtar said he can not.** **
    ‘It doesn’t suit me,’ he said.**

5. Akhtar believed he could have been ‘considered’ for the ongoing three-test series against Sri Lanka as he has regained full fitness.
**

=========Cricinfo

  1. Shoaib Akhtar: “I kept quiet because I have a central contract and didn’t want to offend the PCB.” © Sohail Abbas

  2. Akhtar belongs to category A of the PCB’s centrally contracted players, who are barred from openly criticising the cricket board’s decisions.

  3. The injury-prone fast bowler last played a Test in 2007, against India, before he was sidelined for 14 months with fitness and disciplinary problems. He made two unimpressive comebacks to international cricket this year - in the one-day series at home against Sri Lanka, and the five ODIs and lone Twenty20 against Australia in Abu Dhabi and Dubai. Akhtar, however, believes he can still get back to his best.

  4. He also said he felt shortening his run-up - as suggested by former Pakistan coach Bob Woolmer - would not prolong his career. “It doesn’t suit me,” Akhtar said.

  5. Akhtar believed he could have been picked for the ongoing three-Test series away to Sri Lanka as he had regained full fitness.


Re: Cricinfo copying and pasting from PAK sites!!!

^ damn. that one is pretty damning... number 3 especially.

Re: Cricinfo copying and pasting from PAK sites!!!

I agree - this one has chaapa written all over it !

Re: Cricinfo copying and pasting from PAK sites!!!

who is this Sohail Abbas? has cricinfo started hiring pakistanians to write reports? :mad:

Re: Cricinfo copying and pasting from PAK sites!!!

^ oye yaar queeer itna na sarRa kar

Re: Cricinfo copying and pasting from PAK sites!!!

maybe they are doing content sharing? it is common on the web to do content sharing between sites.. ?

Cricinfo is usually good with citations. I have noticed them giving reference of News or even online forums.