crazy cousins

Sounds like a tough situation all around.

the girl has a right to a life with a husband who is on her won mental level...maybe she wants kids and he can't have any....judging by what you said, she must have been pretty young when she had a nikkah. obviously her own opinion and consent wasn't of importance, neither was her mothers. So your point about why are htey whining now is moot since you sai dso yourself the mothers opinion wasn't given any importance.

however it doesn't give her the right to treat him terribly.... but maybe since she had no say or importance in her llife she doesnt know better....

Secondly... I kinda feel bad for the guy....whatever his own situation is, he too deserves a wife who will care for him and take care of him, as do the in laws.

Also I dont think the family is evil... an evil family wouldn't willingly financially support two families..even if they were to support her after hte nikkah there was no rule that says htey have to support her mother or her siblings...i don't see how u can spend so much money on someone u just don't care about.

im sure they too are heartbroken when they see how she treats them.....maybe for them, the money they provided was their way of showing care (for some people, money is the only way they can show how they care) and in return being treated horribly hurts them....so maybe htey're not "Bragging" but rather lamenting that after all they could do this is how they are repaid....

i think everyone needs to go their separate ways... However if she does divorce, you guys should help her get on her feet..i.e., get a job, find a place to live, or if u dont want her ot live alone, tell her that this is how she will have to live (cleaning up after herself, at least pay for her own stuff etc).. i understand after 5 months of an unwanted guest you feel very annoyed....and she can def have an iattitutde after all she's been through

basically i think everyone here is a victim... =(

wow im done...a whole post without being mean or judgmental, i think im losing my touch :@: