Confused Writers

[muqawwee123]

Have you come across through such writers, who are confused and make people reading their books confused.

Mazhar ul Islam is considered to be a prominent story writer in Pakistan. I bought his book ‘guRiya ki aankh se shehr ko dekho’. The stories are as vague as the title of book.

Is it our liking / disliking of particular writing styles that made writers look confused to us or some writers really doesn’t make any sense.

[hybridkamal]

Re: Confused Writers

Abdullah hussain

[muqawwee123]

Re: Confused Writers

Abdullah hussain

Apart from Udaas Naslen, do his other books fall in this confusing category. Nasheb was also a confused story (but it suited the characters mentioned in the novel) or may be we see at this work from its dramatisation

[hybridkamal]

Re: Confused Writers

@muqawwee123

Apart from Udaas Naslen, do his other books fall in this confusing category. Nasheb was also a confused story (but it suited the characters mentioned in the novel) or may be we see at this work from its dramatisation

yes, i saw nasheb in drama form which was nice, have not read it yet but udaas naslein was confusing at many occasions and another novel baaghh (tiger)

[muqawwee123]

Re: Confused Writers

@hybridkamal

yes, i saw nasheb in drama form which was nice, have not read it yet but udaas naslein was confusing at many occasions and another novel baaghh (tiger)

with all this confusion, the writer and his fans are complaining that Udaas naslen didn’t get its due place as compared to ‘Aag ka Darya’ and Raja Gidh.

Have you tried Mazhar ul Islam?

[hybridkamal]

Re: Confused Writers

with all this confusion, the writer and his fans are complaining that Udaas naslen didn't get its due place as compared to 'Aag ka Darya' and Raja Gidh.

Have you tried Mazhar ul Islam?

aag ka dariya and raja gidh are definetely superior than udaas naslein (though udaas naslein has also its plus points), have not tried mazhar-ul-islam's stories but now yoiu have mentioned so will.