Climate experts : Change strategy now

Climate experts: Change strategy nowJamal Shahid

‹](http://dawn.com/news/1036823/climate-experts-change-strategy-now#gallery) ›](http://dawn.com/news/1036823/climate-experts-change-strategy-now#gallery)

Published 2013-08-19 15:24:30

Share

  • Email*](javascript:void(0)) Receiver Email Sender Name Your Email Cancel

**0 Comment(s) *
** Print *
**



***ISLAMABAD: Meteorologists and environmentalists had long seen heavy monsoon spells coming to Pakistan.
The current downpour only confirmed what they had been reading in the displacement of the monsoon pattern since 1991.
Indeed, their fear that abnormal rainfall may bring destructive floods became a reality in the last year of that decade.
“We believe that the cause of the even more devastating floods in 2010 lay in the shifting of the monsoon pattern from the eastern part of Pakistan to the western part by some 100 kilometres,” said Dr Azmat Hayat Khan, Director of the Meteorological Department of Islamabad.
“Does anyone remember the extreme event of 621mm of rain falling in just eight hours in Islamabad on July 23, 2001?” he asks.

For a huge downpour in such a short time would be of more concern to the people than the shift in the monsoon pattern caused by global warming.
“Rainfall in the twin cities, and all parts of the country, has been unusually heavy and causing flash floods,” the expert told Dawn.
“If nature maintains this pattern, southern Punjab, adjoining Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and southern Pakistan would be twice as vulnerable to serious flooding in the next 30 to 35 years.”
Dr Azmat pinpointed Charsadda, Nowshera, Attock, and Swat as the new vulnerable areas, among others in the western and southern Pakistan.
“These locations require more attention for water management and flood control authorities,” he said, stressing that instead of Kashmir and northern areas, semi-arid regions of Punjab and Khyber Pakhtunkwa and Punjab were receiving more rainfall.
Catchment areas of the existing Mangla dam, and those planned for the immediate future, had been receiving less rains for the last few years, he reminded.
“This means that we need to plan new dams farther down south. We might need a fully-fledged dam at the Jinnah Barrage. There is a definite possibility that Mangla dam becomes obsolete and we might not need the Kalabagh dam if the monsoon pattern keeps shifting farther west,” said the expert.
Dr Azmat explained that the climatic shift posed a serious threat to the agriculture, livelihood, and economies of the semi-arid regions. He cited the poor cotton production of the regions over the last three years as an example.
“We had poor cotton in 2010 because of unusual rains in southern Punjab, areas that receive few rains favourable for cotton production. We are predicting similar unusual rainfalls in 2013 again in the months of August and September when the cotton is likely ready for picking,” he said.
According to the Met Department, of the 100 potentially heavy downpours in the future, top six were likely to occur in western Punjab and the adjoining Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province.
Department experts say the monsoon pattern has altered to such an extent that all four rainfall events – the easterly and westerly currents colliding over the northern areas; the high pressure build over Tibet; depression in the Bay of Bengal and the less frequent westerly currents over Bombay – have deflected into Pakistan.
And all were likely to cause heavy downpours in a short time over western Punjab, adjoining KP and causing floods in Sindh, and even parts of Balochistan.
Dr Ghulam Rasul, Chief Meteorologist at the Pakistan Meteorological Department, also stresses the need for new dams to control and manage the future floods, and indeed use the water for agriculture and energy needs of the country.
“There is no doubt we will see more of such cloudbursts – or even worse – as the one Saidpur village of Islamabad experienced last month, when 130mm rain fell on it in less than one hour. Unless we have new dams down south, nature will wreak havoc,” he warned.
Pervaiz Amir, a senior economist and former member of the Prime Minister’s Task Force on Climate Change, endorsed most of the observations of the meteorologists.
“Extreme events, which the country experienced over longer intervals in the past, are now happening at shorter intervals of two to three years,” he said. “The 2013 rains are likely to wreak the same kind of havoc as in 2010.”
He advised farmers to adjust their crop calendar, sowing cotton two months earlier so that the crop is picked before the monsoon hits. Rice growers, on the other hand, should go for delayed planting.
“There is need to introduce new varieties of wheat, rice and sugarcane which mature faster, survive heavy, unexpected rains and prolonged drought – conditions that have already arrived and are likely to continue for the next 30 to 35 years,” said the economist.


Re: Climate experts : Change strategy now

If monsoon patterns are changing, does that mean that we might see monsoon shift into Afghanistan if it is moving westward? I still don't get why kalabagh won't be "relevant" per the article since the monsoon in nowshera, swat should be better managed in kalabagh, wouldn't it? The only reason that I can waterlogging happening is that if we didn't allow release of water from KBD causing a backflow.

Re: Climate experts : Change strategy now

A lot of people have built successful political careers out of blocking such projects. They cannot give up so easily.

Re: Climate experts : Change strategy now

Interesting, if the weather patterns are changing the government should go for alternate ways to better harness the excess water.

Re: Climate experts : Change strategy now

why only stress on "alternate ways" when it comes to Kalabagh? why not all possible measures?
As per popular narrative in the country at least these days:
PMLN = Punjabi Party
PTI = National Party without ethnic binding
PPP = Sindhi Party
ANP = Pukhtoon Party (no tangible presence anymore)
MQM = self proclaimed middle class representatives, no ethnic base (as per them)

why not two non-ethnic parties come out and support Kalabagh? why Kalabagh? because a lot of research and feasibility work has already been done (more than once) and almost all experts agree that its being delayed because of political reasons all technical reasons can be controlled.
why not PTI passes a resolution in KP assembly that they will support Kalabagh if their so and so technical concerns are addressed? why only stress on alternative? alternatives are fine but need more funds and more time and more research, Kalabagh is like a ready made solution.
i know PTI guys will come back with Soan dam, ye that's an option and must be explored, but as of now it has only been assessed and proposed by a handful of experts, not gone through complete feasibility study and research work on govt level which will take time. its good chance that we have PTI in KP, PMLN in Punjab, and PML+Nationalist in Baluchistan, if these three provinces approve it, and they give its control to Sindh to satisfy their concern that they will be deprived of water if Federation or Punjab controls Kalabagh outflow. if this is done there will be no reason to delay it any further, and no excuse for any party running their shop at the expense of country

Re: Climate experts : Change strategy now

More than PTI/MQM if Kalabagh dam has to be built the nationalist parties ANP, Sindh and Baloch Nationalists need to be convinced. Otherwise they will again get an issue which keeps them in business.

Re: Climate experts : Change strategy now

if PTI is convinced that means KP is convinced, people of KP after all have given mandate to PTI, no? and you cannot make everyone happy at the same time.
biggest hurdle here is KP and Sindh, not Baluchistan. if Control of flow of water is shared between both of them, and Baluchistan gets its land cultivated it will be good enough. many people from Punjab have been saying on record that we will agree to this dam even if Punjab gets no share from water/ canals which this dam will feed. The benefit that 100s of thousand people will not face this flood every few years, and that govt will not have to spend its resources rehabilitating them etc itself is a big benefit which everyone should happily agree to

Re: Climate experts : Change strategy now

Politics of many parties depend upon Kalabagh Dam and other similar issues. ANP is down but not out, concession from PTI on this issue on the one hand can destabilize the provincial government and on the other hand does not mean much as Sindh's reservations will still be there. Best is that the federal government develops a consensus on the issue.

Re: Climate experts : Change strategy now

^ yes right, easy way out from everything is saying "hamaray kehnay say kya hota hay, xyz ko chahye k karay"

Re: Climate experts : Change strategy now

In any case I am not in favor of bigger dams. Besides KPK alone cannot build the dam.

Re: Climate experts : Change strategy now

its not about whether KP can build bigger dam or not, its about showing interest and fixing the opinion of people which is hindering our progress in this domain.

the link you posted says 3 provinces rejected kalabagh, which somewhat strengthens my point that now since KP is ruled by PTI, Punjab by PMLN and Baluchistan by PML+Allies, three provinces this time can easily “approve” of Kalabagh, then likes of sharjeel memon and those who did their politics on this issue will have no choice but to act rationally

Re: Climate experts : Change strategy now

Daily Times - Leading News Resource of Pakistan

VIEW : Courts and the Kalabagh Dam — Arbab Daud

Re: Climate experts : Change strategy now

It should be easier to start from Balochistan then, wean one province and at least there will be parity. At the moment its Punjab versus the rest.

Re: Climate experts : Change strategy now

I think that it is just brotherhood but what does balochistan get from opposing kalabagh? I guess they might be worried that sindh would divert more water out of their share but then balochistan doesn't receive that much water anyway.

Re: Climate experts : Change strategy now

Thank you Allah mian!!

We have people who are looking at what matters.

Pakistan is on drought map, I am glad for now its only a shift.
We would still have water to harness :aisha:

Only it depend on us, if we secure it.

Re: Climate experts : Change strategy now

I hope PTI does not keep block this and works with PML-N/Federal govt to build consensus for Kalabagh dam. In past I read article that even if KB dam was there flooding would've still occurred. But I just checked flood zones of 2010 and 2013 KB dam would've blocked major flooding (not ALL of it).

I don't believe MQM can play any role in Kalabagh dam other than becoming a whiny/cry-baby and join Sindhi nationalists just to oppose KB dam. MQM does not have "landlords", "farmers" on its side, so its mainly PPP's vote which can bring up support for KB dam from Sindh.

Re: Climate experts : Change strategy now

Most of city mentioned in KP are on higher elevation, that means natural advantage.
Water flows down :snooty:

So we should capture all the free/clean water put them in dams, make canals.
Make it blessing rather then problem.

Re: Climate experts : Change strategy now

You talk pakistanis and blessings? We would make it a nuisance if man-o-salva were to start flowing tomorrow.

Re: Climate experts : Change strategy now

true, agreed. but don't we believe PTI is better in terms of policy making and implementing than PMLN? and don't we believe PTI has more patriots than anyone political party? at least this is what i get from this forum, if that is the case, shouldn't PTI take the lead?

Re: Climate experts : Change strategy now

We can't take one forum/media to make our belief :D. Yes as a PTI supporter I would want PTI to do that but considering how PML-N played out national conference on terrorism they will do the same here. PML-N has to take the lead as it is a national issue and take everybody into confidence, then PTI must join PML-N and support the cause.