Clash between Feeling, thinking and Believing

Have you come across such statements:

“Yes, I understand and I believe this is the Sunnah of the Prophet (saw) and he ordered us to do it, which is what we muslims should do, But I Think…, But I feel…”

or

“Yes, I understand and I believe this is what the Prophet (saw) didn’t allow and we muslims shouldn’t do it, But I Think…, But I feel…”

^ I have come across it many times. May Allah forgive me if I have made such big mistakes in life.

I have heard such statements mostly for topics like music, Hijab, Beard…etc.

Re: Clash between Feeling, thinking and Believing

yes...youare right...its very difficult to leave gunah...and adapt good thing..extremely difficult....

Mairi tameer mai muzmir hai ik soorat kharabi ki .....

Re: Clash between Feeling, thinking and Believing

This shows how weak we are in our Faith(Iman).

Re: Clash between Feeling, thinking and Believing

Sunnah is not Farz, Order is Farz.

Re: Clash between Feeling, thinking and Believing

But I am very strong in my faith!

Re: Clash between Feeling, thinking and Believing

i agree...but the shotest path between allah and us is only sunnah..it removes all sins..and create love between allah and his creatures....

Re: Clash between Feeling, thinking and Believing

its very dfficult to overcome "Nafs" ....

Re: Clash between Feeling, thinking and Believing

yeah.....save it.

Re: Clash between Feeling, thinking and Believing

Same here.


Yeah Alhamdolillah Allah ki maharbani say mera faith bhi bohat Strong hai kafi ziada cheezon main.


Yes Tahreem Sis Allah hum sub ko apna Imaan aur ziada mazboot karnay ki salihat day aur issay tadum e marg qaim rakhay.


Ameen.

Re: Clash between Feeling, thinking and Believing

Yes sure it is the place where sometimes or most of the time we become Imaanless.

Re: Clash between Feeling, thinking and Believing

^ i have heard somewhere a quote of a sufi...i forget his name...he said

"Nafs bari ajeeb shai hai...jub burai par uttar aai (nafsa ammara) ...to insaan ko waan pohancha daita hai jahan par haiwaniat bhi sharmati hai...aur agar qaboo mai a gai (nafse mutmainna)to baaz auqat lamho mai insaan ko zameen sai uttha kar 7 asmaa sai bhi ooper pohancha daita hai(as some sufia do in zikar with allah hu ...zarb etc)

Re: Clash between Feeling, thinking and Believing

Bohat sahi baat kahi hay sufi sahab nain.

Re: Clash between Feeling, thinking and Believing

Allah admonishes that owning up to one's mistake, toba and pure form of kneeling and weeping in prayer is listened to by Allah, very closely.
there is a difference in feeling and in behavior.
some behaviors might instinctively feel repelling.
it also depends on the thinking and intelligence of the human being and her/ his personal charater.
and for that Allah has made room.
look for any example between two people, Allah has pre ordained change if that is warranted and if someone is wronged or is uncomfortable.