Is taali bajana as in clapping for someone in appreciation, applauding, wrong in Islam? Why?
Re: Clap clap clap clap clap!
i dont know:hmmm: is it??
Re: Clap clap clap clap clap!
At almost all muslim community events I've see that when people start to clap, they are hushed and asked to say AllahoAkbar instead and today, someone said we are not allowed to clap. I want to know the logic behind that.
Re: Clap clap clap clap clap!
It the the way of non muslims. You have mashallah and subhanallah in Islam you can say.
I was at an opening of a masjid last week and they had invited some councils and chief police inspecters. There were some ulemas sitting there too. The non muslim chief inspector gave a little speech and the crowd that was sitting clapped. Then the second non muslim said some words and again the crowd clapped lol and the strict looking shaykh just started talking that its haram
lol the next speaker was ready to give his speech on the desk and this shaykh just wouldnt stop. He went into the hadiths and daleels of this issue
this shaykh just wouldnt stop. He went into the hadiths and daleels of this issue
could you quote some of the hadees .. I am not aware of any but the one where Prophet stopped people from correcting the imam by clapping .. and that is relevant only to salaat, not to real life
Re: Clap clap clap clap clap!
Well, i can understand if it's a way of worship of the non muslims, but just saying it's the way of non muslims means we cant do half the things we do.
Re: Clap clap clap clap clap!
Well yeah plus another thing i can think of is it creates rhythm thus music. Maybe thats why its haram but its probably not.
Its just against the Adaab of masjid or an islamic gathering. The guy also said it is Jaaiz way of appreciating but not in the masjid so you can still do it outside but not in the masjid
could you quote some of the hadees .. I am not aware of any but the one where Prophet stopped people from correcting the imam by clapping .. and that is relevant only to salaat, not to real life
I was sitting quite far back so i only heard bits of what he said as he hadnt had the mic but i think he talked about the Adaab of masjid
Re: Clap clap clap clap clap!
it should not be. what kind of God would look at every little thing like that.
Well yeah plus another thing i can think of is it creates rhythm thus music. Maybe thats why its haram but its probably not. Its just against the Adaab of masjid or an islamic gathering. The guy also said it is Jaaiz way of appreciating but not in the masjid so you can still do it outside but not in the masjid
But I've seen that outside of a masjid set up as well. That is the thing.
outside its ok i guess...he said it is an acceptable form of appreciation but not in masjid
Re: Clap clap clap clap clap!
it's just a manners and etiquettes thing i think....
Re: Clap clap clap clap clap!
even in some churchs they frown upon clapping....
Re: Clap clap clap clap clap!
hmmmm.
I totally understand the etiquettes part, but yesterday, this person who is very learned and qualified and usually very particular about the information she passes to other mentioned that it is not allowed in Islam...and that got me thinking. I did not ask her because I had to leave right after that but I will ask her later. Meanwhile I thought I'd check for some anwers here.
Re: Clap clap clap clap clap!
the disbelievers used to clap and whistle while Prophet PBUH used to be praying
Re: Clap clap clap clap clap!
oh now that makes sense.
Re: Clap clap clap clap clap!
=)
the disbelievers used to clap and whistle while Prophet PBUH used to be praying
so clapping should be ban as form of mocking then, should not be ban as form of appreciation ..
Like it was also not recommended to speak louder than the prophet. Sahaba were extremely careful about that never to raise their voices in front of Prophet, but in general (and in shariyat) that does not prohibit people from speaking louder if needed
so clapping should be ban as form of mocking then, should not be ban as form of appreciation ..
Like it was also not recommended to speak louder than the prophet. Sahaba were extremely careful about that never to raise their voices in front of Prophet, but in general (and in shariyat) that does not prohibit people from speaking louder if needed
i aint a molvi but i even read somewhere that when woman are in offerinf salah and u see something deadly happening as in fire or a snake then one can clap to bring attention .That is a different case may be
on the other hand i have evn heard people saying that clapping in a gathering brings shetan.a better way to appriciate is to say SubhanAllah or Mashallah.Prophet PBUH ke time main aisay hi appriciate kiya jata tha