'Cinderella law' being considered in UK

BBC News - NSPCC refers more child emotional abuse case referrals
The number of child emotional abuse cases referred to police and children’s services by the NSPCC has risen by 47% in a year, the charity has said.

Its helpline received about 8,000 calls in 2013-14 about such non-physical cruelty, and 5,354 were thought serious enough to merit further inquires.

Ministers are seeking to update laws on emotional abuse in England and Wales.

In total, more than 60,000 people contacted the NSPCC helpline, an increase of 21% on 2012-13.
The figures have been released as the government considers a potential change in the law to specifically target the emotional neglect and abuse of children.

The so-called Cinderella Law, if passed, would amend the Children and Young Persons Act of 1933, which currently states that a person should be punished for treating a child “in a manner likely to cause him unnecessary suffering or injury to health”.

A proposed bill would add a further category of harm for which the perpetrator could be punished for impairment of “physical, intellectual, emotional, social or behavioural development”.
The NSPCC’s head of child protection operations, John Cameron, said if the government were to push through the law it would be a positive step forward.

He added: "We must ensure we support children’s services and that the police are given better powers to prosecute those who subject children to emotional neglect and abuse…

“But a law alone is not enough. What we really need to do is work together to prevent this abuse happening in the first place.”

His sentiments were echoed by Sir Tony Hawkhead, the chief executive of fellow charity Action for Children, who said the NSPCC’s rise in calls and referrals showed the “scale and seriousness of emotional abuse”.

The Ministry of Justice has previously confirmed it was “considering ways the law can support” protecting children from emotional abuse.

It said protecting children from harm was “fundamental” and that child cruelty was an “abhorrent crime which should be punished”.

Re: 'Cinderella law' being considered in UK

Good on paper. But when you get a bunch of barely educated gits making a call if a child was abused or not...

Re: ‘Cinderella law’ being considered in UK

Oh God, does UK really need this? A glance at a child can now get you charged with emotional abuse :smack:

Re: ‘Cinderella law’ being considered in UK

Oh dear. This law is far too vague to be enforced effectively. Treating a child “in a manner likely to cause him unnecessary suffering or injury to health” could mean loads of things. “Unnecessary suffering” is quite relative and opens the door to frivolous reports. Some children find that their parents cause them “unnecessary suffering” when their parents prevent them running amok and from doing whatever they like or ask them to clean up after themselves. :smack:

Re: ‘Cinderella law’ being considered in UK

Not just parents, anyone who is around the child. Teachers, care takers, nannies, some poor guy at McDonalds that doesn’t give the kid a toy can be charged with this law. This law would be such a slippery slope.

Re: 'Cinderella law' being considered in UK

Spare the rod and spoil the child.

Re: 'Cinderella law' being considered in UK

Cinderella was thin because she was deprived of food, humble because she was deprived of luxuries, she came out on top ... This law should really be called the Ugly Step Sister Law - because it wants all children to be equally as ugly-step-sister-ish as everyone else.