CIA finds no proof of Iran making Nuclear Weapons

CIA has so far no evidence that Iran is bent on Making Nuclear Weapons. Either Iran is really good in hiding stuff or in reality Iran has no intention of making Nuclear Weapons.

In any case, a military strike on Iran looks remote after this.

Here is the original article

http://www.newyorker.com/fact/content/articles/061127fa_fact

The US Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) has not found conclusive evidence that Iran is developing nuclear weapons, a US magazine has reported.

Veteran investigative reporter Seymour Hersh, writing in The New Yorker, cites a secret CIA report based on intelligence such as satellite images.

Correspondents say the alleged document appears to challenge Washington’s views regarding Iranian nuclear intentions.

The article says the White House was dismissive about the CIA report.

The US and Europe say Iran is pursuing a clandestine nuclear weapons programme - a charge Iran has strongly denied.

The CIA assessment, according to unnamed officials quoted in the article, casts doubt on how far Iran has actually progressed to making a nuclear weapon.

The White House is not going to dignify the work of an author who has viciously degraded our troops.

Dana Perino White House spokeswoman “The CIA found no conclusive evidence, as yet, of a secret Iranian nuclear weapons program running parallel to the civilian operations that Iran has declared to the International Atomic Energy Agency,” Mr Hersh wrote.

It says the agency based its conclusions on technical intelligence, such as satellite photography and measurements from sensors planted by US and Israeli agents.

The article says: “A current senior intelligence official confirmed the existence of the CIA analysis, and told me that the White House had been hostile to it.”

White House spokeswoman Dana Perino criticised the article, calling it an “error-filled” piece in a “series of inaccuracy-riddled articles about the Bush administration”.

“The White House is not going to dignify the work of an author who has viciously degraded our troops, and whose articles consistently rely on outright falsehoods to justify his own radical views,” she was quoted by AFP news agency as saying.

The BBC’s Adam Brookes in Washington says if the New Yorker article is correct, it would suggest that the CIA is being more cautious than the Bush administration in evaluating whether or not Iran is on its way to building a bomb.

And he says, as with Iraq, it suggests political battles to come over how intelligence is used as a basis for American foreign policy.

Re: CIA finds no proof of Iran making Nuclear Weapons

Military strike on Iran looked remote even before this obvious news.

Re: CIA finds no proof of Iran making Nuclear Weapons

i am shocked out of my mind!! that the truth leaked to the media!
I don't understand...the CIA ...honest!! r pigs flying yet?!!
i dont know i dont trust the CIA! but wizard u are right it would have been difficult to attack iran even before. Considering that US forces are too busy as is in iraq, and the bare minimum control over iraq right now is due to the allainces with the shia factions which will not remain if there is an attack on iran!

mercenery why do u think iran is good at hiding .... its already been said that Iran does not have the technological capabiliites to make a nuclear weapon. furthermore, since iran is run largely by its religious clerics..who oppose developing nuclear weapon. shia clerics have long frowned upon developing nuclear weapons, infact the reason why Iran (unlike india and pakistan) signed on, and was, and continues to be the NPT's (nuclear - non proliferation treaty)'s most ardent followers and advocate is b/c they dont think nuclear weapon proliferation is a good thing. the religious heirarchy would have to change, or do a 180 to suddenly want and develop nuclear weapons.

Re: CIA finds no proof of Iran making Nuclear Weapons

Actually CIA did say that Iraq had no WMD but Bush and Company were hell bent on invading it so that evidence was by passed. CIA and FBI also alerted that Al Qaeda terrorists were in USA but again Bush and Company were too busy planning to invade Iraq to take Al Qaeda terrorists seriously.

As for Iran.

My personal feeling is that Iran is not making nuclear weapons but is also making sure that it has the capability to develop them indeginously in the future if such a need arises.

Re: CIA finds no proof of Iran making Nuclear Weapons

I would like to see Iran as a nuclear state, but they are not going to be nuclear. Iran is a theocracy, and their maulanas have declared nuclear weapons as inhumane and un-Islamic.

As far as Israel is concerned, Iran does not need nuclear weapons for them.

Re: CIA finds no proof of Iran making Nuclear Weapons

they were not going to attack Iran anyways. I mean they're already stuck in both Iraq & Afghanistan. Besides Iran is much more stronger than these 2 countries. Its more stable politically, economically etc etc.

How come the truth is leaked. It might be on purpose. Maybe they've decided to leak it on purpose to get rid of it. Because they can't really attack iran at the moment. And they might thought of clearing the whole situation this way.

Re: CIA finds no proof of Iran making Nuclear Weapons

Iran does not have dissident groups like northern alliance in Afghanistan or shiite/kurds in Iraq. Us will have to wait till it can get enough inside support, i wonder who cud it be? the anti-theocracy?

Re: CIA finds no proof of Iran making Nuclear Weapons

Iran is going to be attacked next year.. Yes, it look like unlikely to many, but it look like a sure shot to me.. not because they are building nuclear weapons or hiding them efficiently... but because they want to prove a point that they are still great millitary power... unfortunately it will just accelerate the sad demise of the america... when you are in quick sand you behave energetically and that just speed up your death... so is the case here.. Americans are already in quick sand.. they are not ready to take a breath and relax and return to the policy of live and let live..

Just my thoughts.

Re: CIA finds no proof of Iran making Nuclear Weapons

Iran is not as strong as you would like to beleive.

Iran's entire military structure is obselete. Their tanks, planes, ships are 20-30 years behind today's technology.

As for Iran's missiles, they are just a shoddy reverse engineered North Korean Missiles and we all know how pathetically they failed in this Summer's test.

Iran's real danger comes in non-military terms.

Iran can use Hezbollah to launch terrorist attacks throughout the world.
Iran can send suicide squads in Iraq to target American troops.
By attacking Iran, the oil prices throughout the world will increase.
Russia and China will be against such an attack.

That is the danger that Iran poses.

Re: CIA finds no proof of Iran making Nuclear Weapons

Good point brother,

  1. For a while it seemed to me USA was itching for a fight with Iran, over the nuclear weapons issue, even though Iran has denied it is developing nukes.
  2. N.Korea blatantly carries out nuclear testing,
  3. Then the CIA suddenly finds no conclusive evidence that Iran is developing Nuclear arms.
    ( Coincidence :confused: or not. )

4.suddenly there is a hush in the media reagrding Iran and its Nukes.

Re: CIA finds no proof of Iran making Nuclear Weapons

You hit the nail right on the head, sit tight and wait US will wiggle and jiggle its butt few more times before finding another customer.