China Silenced: Being Muslim in China

So one youtube video after another i ended up on a few related to chinese muslims. I have always been fascinated by muslims in china. Today i learnt that there is a mosque in China dating back to 960 AD, even before islam came to the subcontinent.

This documentary is about the plight of the people of the Xinjiang province on the northwest, the one that borders with Pakistan and Afghanistan. China took over this region by force 50 years ago and has since policed this area very strictly, severely limiting freedom of speech and travel. Majority of local residents are musilms called *Uyghur *(the word itself has become a derogatory term in maintream china).

A very heartbreaking 15 minute report.

Re: China Silenced: Being Muslim in China

Shockin !

Re: China Silenced: Being Muslim in China

:-(

Re: China Silenced: Being Muslim in China

be suspicious of these kinds of reports on the internet, sometimes they are only designed to destabilise and paint pictures

Re: China Silenced: Being Muslim in China

I say we liberate Ughuir Muslims....its Part of Pakistan....we should reclaim it back from China. They are culturally and religiously more like us..their bazaars and looks remind me of people from Gilgit and Hunza Valley in Pakistan.....
I think we should infilterate freedom fighters from Pakistan into China and teach these chinese a lesson!

Re: China Silenced: Being Muslim in China

^^ I think you should hire a maulvi to teach u a lesson.

Re: China Silenced: Being Muslim in China

Or maybe just open our doors to those people? Strike a deal with Chinese authorities and allow these people to come to Pakistan and settle here?

Re: China Silenced: Being Muslim in China

The Chinese government should not be trusted so blindly by Pakistan. Their track record against Tibet and Muslims is very bad. Pakistan should push China for better treatment of Muslims.

Re: China Silenced: Being Muslim in China

Interesting...thanks for sharing.

Re: China Silenced: Being Muslim in China

I say we give them Military Training in Pakistan...Give them arms and create a rebellion ....that will teach China a lesson

Re: China Silenced: Being Muslim in China

^^ China is our trusted ally. We cannot do this to the Chinese. And China is a communist state.

And besides Muslims don't want to make another enemy with China.

Pretty much all the major world powers are fighting Muslims.

Whether its USA, Europe, Russia and India.

And 2nd Tier powers such as Thailand, Philippines, Brazil, Argentina, South Africa. We don't need another enemy in China

Re: China Silenced: Being Muslim in China

I thought i heard somewhere Xinjiang has open borders with Pakistan. Does that mean for trade only or for travel as well?

Re: China Silenced: Being Muslim in China

so if they were showing something against India, Israel or USA...would your reaction be the same?

Re: China Silenced: Being Muslim in China

you guys!!! some of you guys support anything tribal looking that can carry an ak47. this report is BS, its made up and even acted out.

these people are more closer to mongolia, kazakhstan and russia then pakistan. they are on the far north west of china. they do have a slight murmerings of independence (less then balochistan) but they are chinese and they should aim to grow with china. its an internal chinese problem, without much scope for foreign intel to cause problems. with chinas strict approach to separatists and the areas growing economy, xingjang is going nowhere

economic info:
Xinjiang’s nominal GDP was approximately 187 billion RMB (about 23 billion USD) in 2003, and increased to 220 billion RMB (about 28 billion USD) in 2004, due to the China Western Development policy introduced by the State Council to boost economic development in Western China. Its per capita GDP for 2003 was 9,710 RMB (1172 USD).
Oil and gas extraction industry in Aksu and Karamay is booming, with the West-East Gas Pipeline connecting to Shanghai.
Xinjiang’s exports amounted to 3.047 billion USD, while import turned out to be 2.589 billion USD in 2004. Most of the overall import/export volume in Xinjiang was directed to and from Kazakhstan through Ala Pass .

Re: China Silenced: Being Muslim in China

israel stole pal land,
kashmir is unresolved and needs pleblicite to resolve
usa have questions to answer on iraq

reactions are related to your personal viewpoints on each subject

Re: China Silenced: Being Muslim in China

^ The figures you state above are all really nice and dandy. Baluchistan has similar figures for producing natural gas.. but exactly how many baluchis benefit from this export? Iraq has the world's 4th largest oil reserve.. but how many iraqis benefit from the resource? Xinjiang is controlled by the powerful eastern block run by Han chinese who claim to be a more educated, superior race. How can you say for sure that all the money made in Xinjiang is actually being spent on the locals?

Re: China Silenced: Being Muslim in China

Exactly

Xinjiang was never a part of China. It was an autonomous state just like Tibet.

China after the civil war ended in 1949, took over Tibet and then Xinjiang in 1950 and then wanted to take over Taiwan.

Re: China Silenced: Being Muslim in China

I don’t know if you are being sarcastic or serious, but one thing that I do know for sure is that these people would probably have better standards of living while living in China rather than in Pakistan. Look at what happened when we opened our doors to the Afghan refugees. You talk as if they will have more oppurtunities in Pakistan. Pakistan is behind China in all fields, including economy, health, SoL, and most importantly, poverty. Not to forget, area-wise, Pakistan is more over-populated than China, and has made no effort in curbing this growth rate.

Both.
Kashgar (Xinjiang) is connected by the Karokuram Highway, to Abbottabad (NWFP), and branches of to the GT road (islamabad). Buses run regularly from Gilgit to Kashgar. The borders are open for both travelling and trade.

Comparing Baluchistan’s gas production (resource) figures with Xinjiang’s economic indicators (social & economic development measures) is absurd. The money made in Xinjiang and being spent on the locals is visible through the figures posted by vroom, and such figures do not exist for Baluchistan, sadly, some don’t for even the whole of Pakistan.

Pictures speak a thousand words:
http://content.answers.com/main/content/wp/en/5/51/Urumqi_panorama.jpg

^^ Compare this to Baluchistan and Iraq.

Re: China Silenced: Being Muslim in China

I don’t know if you are being sarcastic or serious, but one thing that I do know for sure is that these people would probably have better standards of living while living in China rather than in Pakistan. Look at what happened when we opened our doors to the Afghan refugees. You talk as if they will have more oppurtunities in Pakistan. Pakistan is behind China in all fields, including economy, health, SoL, and most importantly, poverty. Not to forget, area-wise, Pakistan is more over-populated than China.

Both.
Kashgar (Xinjiang) is connected by the Karokuram Highway, to Abbottabad (NWFP), and branches of to the GT road (islamabad). Buses run regularly from Gilgit to Kashgar. The borders are open for both travelling and trade.

Comparing Baluchistan’s gas production (resource) figures with Xinjiang’s economic indicators (social & economic development measures) is absurd. The money made in Xinjiang and being spent on the locals is visible through the figures posted by vroom, and such figures do not exist for Baluchistan, sadly, some don’t for even the whole of Pakistan.

Pictures speak a thousand words:
http://content.answers.com/main/content/wp/en/5/51/Urumqi_panorama.jpg
http://www.jamestown.org/images/photos/Urumqi_Summer02.JPG

^^ Compare this to Baluchistan and Iraq.

Re: China Silenced: Being Muslim in China

u should sent ur "mujahids" to uighur region as well just like u do in kashmir and did in afghanistan. neways..every country has it's own double standard policies...