Child Adoption

[AllahkaBanda]

Re: Child Adoption

as-salaamu alaykum

Bimsillah

@Mirch

First of all my apology for mixing the name of Sahih Bukhari with Sahih Muslim. I have seen those ahadees in Sahih Muslim not in Sahih Bukhari.

May Allah preserve you

@Mirch

If you do not consider this as authentic source of Sahih Muslim you can open an authentically printed Sahih Muslim and see for yourself.

Allhamdulillah, I’m aware about these ahadith. The reasons I asked you to post them were 2:

1. You mentioned Bukhari which wasn’t correct as you rectified it yourself
2. You said many ahadith mentioning grown up kids breast fed by women. Notice all the plurals here. However, what we have here is few narrations, narrating one incident with slight different wording and perhaps via different routes. Notice how the chapter is titled: “SUCKLING OF A YOUNG (BOY)”.

Now Allahu A’lam if this was an intentional mistake on your part due to ignorance or unintentional.

@Mirch

For second part I ask counter question will any teachings of Islam allow this suckling of milk by boys of the age which are mentioned here ?

The burden of proof is not on my shoulder to prove that these are not against the teachings of Islam. Rather you’re the one who claimed that they’re against the teachings of Islam; hence, the burden of proof is on your shoulder: innocent until proven guilty. I’m interested to know what scientific approach you use to say these ahadith are against the teachings of Islam; hence, they must be rejected. You say it with such confidence and surety as if there’s an established principle and/or text which says otherwise.

and Allah knows best