i know you wanted to discuss the matam issue..i was just listening to a majlis online and the scholer does talk about this issue for few minutes at the end..if u do get a chance..do listen to it
http://www.almohsin.net/majalis.html listen to the majlis from 3rd mohurram…its not that long so i ask u to listen to the whole majlis but if u just wana listen to the matam topic then listen to atleast the last 20 minutes of the majlis
Thank you very much Sheraz…I really appreciate your effort of going through and putting this up for me…I did listen to it …Thanks…:k:
Forgive me, but I reject everything the gentleman said…We will InshAllah discuss this after Moharram, InshAllah…Right now I believe you have to go through a lot…
Please refrain from indulging in sectarian discussion
It is Ashura and sacred for all of us.
[/QUOTE]
Yaar ..thats why i have given the notice of me joining..:D
in other thread u asked me and sheraz...to stop ....i although was just answering him ....stopped......he carried on
i dont want to start secretarian discusion...but if one is ongoing...would really want to keep record straight...
Two things as I skipped to the last as you said that the relevant topic would be at the end…
One thing which I didn’ grasp how, when the Prophet :saw: was kissing Hazrat Ali , Hazrat Ali grabbed the Holy Prophet :saw:'s tongue with his teeth and sucked all the wisdom and intelligence from the Prophet :saw:'s tongue…
Second, I do not understand how Hazrat Hussain would know the ‘razamandi’ or will of Allah (swt)? The scholar says, even on TV in Prime, that Hazrat Hussain (razi) knows Allah (swt)'s razamandi (Nauzubillah)…How is the possible when even the Prophets didn’t know that?
Third, the Example of Hazrat Yaqub (as) and Hazrat Yousuf (as) does not apply to the case of Hazrat Hussain (razi) because:
That was a case of one Prophet mourning the death of another Prophet and Hazrat Hussain (razi) was not a Prophet…
Hazrat Hussain (razi) was a Shaheed while Hazrat Yousuf (as) was purported to have fallen down a well…